Wolter's Shoreview Supper Club - Amery, Wisconsin

Dan M.

Drinks were good.....salad bar was ok...prime rib and fillet was a joke. All food seamed to be from a microwave oven. Sent it all back. Want to try this place since 1973! Don't bother to go.

emma G.

Went out to try something new. Andrea our server was great! The bartender was also lovely and assisted with a wine recommendation. Wine was a very generous pour as well! Food was sub par at best. I had the NY strip with 3 grilled shrimp. Was cooked the way I asked, but was also under seasoned and the mushrooms on it were obviously canned. (Yuck!) my shrimp were lovely! Friend I was with ordered the grilled walleye, you could tell it was a frozen filet and had tons of bones in it.
Won’t be our first choice, but we may try again maybe when they’re busier in the summer and are going through more product.

John S.

Bad experience Valentine's Day poor slow service,disappointing salad bar, undercooked shrimp and baked potato. $ 42 prime rib was served on a cold plate with mystery ?au Jous ? 1/2" lake in plate. " Complementary glass of champagne " was flat warm and served in a plastic highball glass .

Keith A.

Tonight and my 105th different Wisconsin Supper Club brought me to Amery and a first time visit to Wolter's Shoreview Supper Club . It is on pike lake , next to a campground, and such a beautiful location. I got there with a friend at 4 as they were opening. We walked in as the first guests but filled in shortly after with mainly locals. Started at the bar with Monkey Shoulder Whiskey Manhattan as we talked to 85 yo owner and bartender Tony on the history. He also gave us a tour of all the memorabilia including all the vintage miniature automobile decanters. I remember my dad and grandparents having those too. We ordered shrimp cocktail as appetizers as well as combo platter of breaded mushrooms, cheese curds, and chicken bites. They jumbo shrimp were a good size. Shortly after another round of drinks we were escorted to our table by our waitress Amanda. Such a pretty name. If you read all my posts and you know me you know why. We went to our table and started with the soup and salad bar. Homemade cucumber salad and potatoe salads were big hits. Our table ordered Saturday nights king cut prime rib medium rare, ribs, and seafood platter and also to taste shore fries, au gratin potatoes, and garlic mashed potatoes. Everything was delicious. The prime rib was one of the best I've had in the area. I believe the cook was owner Tony Wolters son. After dinner our waitress asked if we would like complimentary dessert. We were so full but couldn't say no.

They also have a special German Oktoberfest menu starting next week. It's still warm but it's that time of year.

Justin B.

This place is Terrible, service is the worst I’ve seen almost anywhere and the food is disgusting at best …. My GF found an Asian beatle in her dinner and my food came out ice cold , avoid this place at all cost …

Amery W.

Went there with my family the owner is super rude my burger was pink on the inside and the bar owner will call the cops on fisherman if he’s having a bad day do not recommend

Jaime &. Z. N.

Went here for dinner. The service was...not great. We had to seat ourselves and it was about 15 minutes before we even saw A server let alone OUR server. She finally came over and gave us water and took the drink order. She was pretty friendly though at least.
Took another 15 minutes to get two sodas and she took our food order. We both had the soup and salad bar which was mediocre at best. They were pretty much out of soup at 7:30. The lettuce was almost gone but enough for two of us. There were onion slices, cottage cheese, bacon bits, and croutons and that was it. I didn't have the dinner roll but my boyfriend said it was good.
The food surprisingly didn't take too long. I had the prime rib. Was it good? Yes it was actually really tasty. Was it worth $40? No. While the flavor was good, it was a lot smaller and tougher than it should have been for that price. My boyfriend had the fish fry and he said that was really good and at $16 it was much more worth the price.
The server brought boxes and the check pretty quickly but only because I flagged her down when she was helping someone else. She left the check and we waited for about 20 more minutes before we gave up and just put cash down and left.
Overall we were pretty disappointed with the experience. The food was good but it was very overpriced and the service was definitely lacking.

Kylie K.

I don’t like to leave a bad review but boy do they need some help here. Waited over 20 minutes to be helped. Asked the 2 waitresses sitting rolling silverware if I could grab menus because we hadn’t been helped yet. They said sure. Never let anyone else know.

A server came, she was nice. Said they didn’t know whose table it was. (I’ve served I understand) but to walk by 10+ times without a word or look is crazy. We got the wrong drink 2x, I got an Apple martini and it was terrible. The German platter food was good. Salad bar was very lack luster.