Uncle Carlo's Italian Ristorante - Lake Park, Georgia

Rebecca B.

My husband and I are frequent customers. We love their pepperoni pizza! The sauce is freshly made, the crust is always crispy, never greasy. We also recommend their absolutely delicious Nonna's lasagna, which includes ham and eggs, very unique recipe, but so yummy! The traditional spaghetti (I recommend the Angel Hair pasta; you have to request it when placing your order) is really tasty as well.

Wild S. S.

Awesome atmosphere, awesome tasty Italian food, and gelato here. I've been coming here for nearly 3 years, even living in another state, and I'm always desired to come when I have that craved for Carlos special recipe cooking since they make it from scratch. I met the owner a few times, he's very nice and hoping he makes it through many more years 🙏.

Kermit J.

Don't let the strip mall location fool you - this is one of the best Italian restaurants I've ever been to ... and that includes a trip to Italy. MAMA MIA! My family puts it in the top TWO overall (that's a wife and four daughters).

Where to start? The Alfredo was amazing and the chicken I added was unbelievable. Chicken parmesan? Amazing. Cannoli? Fresh and crisp. Not too sweet. Even the cheese pizza was delicious.

And Hannah, our waitress, was excellent with the service. Made great recommendation, kept the water glasses filled, and was pleasant to be around.

If we are EVER driving I-75 and transitioning from Florida to Georgia - this place WILL be on the list.

Skye K.

My girlfriend and I ate here for the first time the other night. The inside was very nice but not over the top, family friendly. Our server was very nice, informative and helpful since we expressed it being our first time. I also liked seeing the owner out in the dining room serving and clearing tables off. I asked if he was the owner he said yes and was very nice also. The food was good, we ordered the potato croquette, (recommended by our server) which I've never had before it was good with their homemade marinara sauce. My girlfriend ordered the Alfredo with chicken which was good and chicken was tasty and flavorful. I ordered the Italian flag which was also good. I loved the plate presentation each pasta was served in an individual bowl. It's ravioli, cheese or meat, which I got the meat, Alfredo and pesto. It was decently priced to for the amount of food. Would for sure go there again!

Mark S.

This is one of the best pizza I've had. Got the Nonna's lasagna pizza. Delicious! Allie was our server and was really sweet. The place was super clean. Will definitely be back.

Rawa

The food was less than average, the service was really bad. Our server was super grumpy and not friendly at all. The lamp above us had spider web as well. The prices also were overrated, it’s a small town restaurant with big city prices and okay quality. The shrimp Alfredo had exactly 6 shrimps. Not a place I would go to again for Italian food.

Jordyn E.

This place was so cute and homey. Our waitress was super sweet and helpful. The food was absolutely amazing! You could really tell it was all made fresh to order. The Gelato was so good and they let us try different flavors. I also got a cannoli and it's the best I've ever had. Will definitely be coming back again and again!

Melissa H.

I will not give them a bad review but I will say they need to reprimand or fire the cook tonight. Not only did the cook ruin my meal experience at this restaurant the first time but he ruined the family's meal that was sitting in front of me. It's pretty sad when your cook messes up two orders of the same thing. I ordered the steak Sicilian Palermo that was almost $40 and it looked nothing like they described it in the menu. My steak was so undercooked it was bleeding everywhere. I asked for pasta with very little sauce and it was swimming in sauce. I felt like the cook tried to cover up my steak in about a half inch of what seemed like Italian bread crumbs or seasoned bread crumbs. My meal was supposed to have some kind of red wine braised cherry tomatoes under it. It honestly looked like they put my steak on top of some cherry pie filling with some odd-looking tomatoes that look like they stole off of somebody's salad. It was supposed to have some kind of anchovy caper thing covering the steak and instead they just toasted up some bread crumbs and smothered it in it. Pretty sad that the cook ruined two good rib eyes and two people's orders. I refuse to pay for my order since it was inedible. The family across from me whose meal was ruined also only ate a few bites of their food and they all packed up their stuff to go. You could tell they were not happy either. Other than that the place was actually great and the service was great.