Tally Ho Supper Club - Hayward, Wisconsin

Mike S.

Love this place! The family owned touches really shine through in their dishes and friendly service. Had the Saturday night prime rib. Everything I wanted it to be.

Sandra B.

The homemade prime rib vegetable soup soup was the best soup in my lifetime. Have it as a meal in itself. The homemade garlic rolls were made from scratch that morning and coated with butter and garlic spices. We seven layer pasta baked lasagna. It was homemade as is most of the menu. It was absolutely to die for. Rob, the owner greeted all the tables and was very involved. We loved the atmosphere, the vibes, and the traditional supper club feel. There are beautiful supper club items like the old time vintage wooden matchsticks and celery trays.

Emma J.

Love it here. Fanciest place of the northwoods! Was met with a cloth napkin placed on my lap. Drinks are phenomenal. The server is so hardworking. 100% recommend this place to anyone searching for a higher end restaurant. They even make their own ranch and everything but the cheese on the relish tray is made in house. Definitely don’t find service like this elsewhere. Thank you!

Tresca M.

This restaurant has mixed reviews for a reason - when it’s not busy, I’m sure they can make it work, but when it’s busy beware! Our experience with service was exactly like the other one star reviews - extremely long wait times and I honestly think they forgot to put in our food order once, maybe twice. We got served dinner at 10pm for a 7:30pm reservation… and all they did was offer apologies and a free third round of drinks. Who wants that when you still haven’t eaten No reduction on the bill or honesty about what happened. Do not seat a table on a busy night if you can’t serve them well - or hire more people to help. Very disappointing experience for the price.

Mary D.

Outstanding food, service and drinks. Tom and family have created a place that is first on the list when family visits. A night at Tally Ho is a request that we gladly honor. The wonderful greeting by Tom makes us feel like family and is only surpassed by the variety of food and superior service. Once you have been here you will be back!

Kevin

Highlights from my group's NYE dinner:

1) when asked if there were any vegetarian options for one of the guests, the chef came out and (genuinely) offered that they could bring out a "smaller portion" of meat for them. Unreal.

2) for the pasta dish, the pasta was overcooked, the sauce watery, the meatballs underwhelming.

3) one person, who asked for medium-well, received medium-rare.

4) another asked for medium and received medium-well (they were different cuts of meat, not swapped).

5) a small slice of cake included for dessert that was underwhelming, possibly frozen and thawed rather than made from scratch.

Even by casual standards (sans casual prices) - service felt lackadaisical, arrogant, and borderline argumentative. Cuisine (for the menu offered) felt reliant on simple dishes not requiring much technique, as well as being entirely overpriced.

I'm flabbergasted how anyone could recommend this place. Please don't eat here.

Tanya K.

Greated right away. We were not told about the long wait to get a table. Had drinks at the bar. The food was good but it took a really long time for it to arrive after ordering. We only came here because the wait at The Ranch was 90 minutes. We both said we should have waited there. We ordered prime rib. While in the restroom, they told my husband they only had one left. He ended up ordering a steak and lobster. My prime rib was really good, and he said his food was good. We both wanted the prime rib. If we knew how long the wait was, we would have ordered while at the bar. The man bartender was very nice. I believe he may have been the owner. Food was very expensive, but good.

Deborah L.

Just finished our anniversary celebration meal at Tally Ho and were thrilled with the scallops we ordered. The wine menu is diverse and plentiful. Dessert selection was delectable, so we went with 3. The service was perfection!!