Tailgaters & IL Primo Buckeye - Buckeye, Arizona

Kristie M.

My order was totally messed up. Wanted my Cobb salad with blue cheese crumble on the side and wanted to add bell peppers. The blue cheese was NOT on the side it was in the salad. There were NO bell peppers added. They gave me no ranch for the salad. No ranch for my wings and they charge $2 for extra sauce which both sauces were suppose to be different but they were the same. Asked for thin crust on BOTH pizzas and only one of them was thin crust. The BBQ chicken pizza had Harley any BBQ sauce. Very disappointing. The guy taking the order was not very sure how to use the POS machine. Overall my experience was not good. Will honestly rethink going here in the future. Maybe Bootys will be better.

Robert H. (.

I've been here before. I felt this was a good time for a review. This restaurant is always clean and organized. The menu is vast And has plenty of items to choose from. I like the food service here but the associates seem to lack passion. Maybe it's just me?

Keonimana P.

I recently visited Tailgaters, and Kristy, the bartender, made my experience truly unforgettable. From the moment I stepped up to the bar, her customer service was exceptional. She greeted me with a genuine smile and immediately made me feel welcome, as if I were a regular. Her positive energy and friendly conversation created a warm, inviting atmosphere.

Kristy’s attentiveness is unmatched—despite a busy night, she never missed a beat. She remembered my order perfectly and always made sure my drink was just right. It’s clear she values her customers, always checking in to see if everything was okay and ensuring everyone felt taken care of. Her efficiency and ability to handle multiple orders without compromising quality or service is truly impressive.

If you’re looking for top-tier customer service, Kristy is the reason to visit Tailgaters. Her dedication to making sure every guest has an amazing experience stands out, and it’s why I’ll be coming back. She’s a true gem behind the bar!

The bone-in medium wings are absolutely amazing here as well, great flavor, size, and not dry at all.

Dokk-David S.

Good food, outstanding service!!! All the servers did an excellent job and we're super friendly!! Five stars
It's a sports bar, so it has a sports bar atmosphere, if that's your thing, awesome. Not my favourite, hard to hear and talk to family over the noise. That's my 3 stars for atmosphere. But I would still highly recommend for the great service food.

Brittany A.

Finally gave it a try as my friend recommended it. We ordered two 16 inch pizzas and 10 piece bone in wing. We received one correct pizza and one wrong. Sadly the mistaken pizza was a waste as my kids wouldn’t eat it. Wings were really good 👍. I am happy they deliver with everything so far. 50/50

Antonio F.

The Calzone was really good, just like the service. Great spot for drinks before or after work.

Matthew W.

We used to love this place. Tonight we made a delivery order. After an hour and a half, we called to get the status. We spoke to the receptionist and she stated we had canceled our order after calling in. Never happened. After being put on hold the manager told us that she was on the way to deliver the food but she received a call that we asked for it to be held and that we would pick it up. Different story and also not the truth. She then stated that she would get the food that was sitting there for an hour delivered. She did offer to recook it but our trust factor was gone. Had to cancel it. I do not mind mistakes but being lied to is a problem.

Stacy B.

First time visiting since they opened. I remembered why we hadn't visited. Service was friendly, but I assume the kitchen is slow. Food took forever and was really disappointing. Ordered the loaded tots, and while the tots were crunchy and plenty of bacon and onion, it was lacking cheese. Ordered a sample platter. 10 zucchini coins, 3 mozzarella sticks, 3 onion rings, and 2 potato skins. Sticks were undercooked, potato undercooked, rings and zucchini were great, but I would have liked some balance. If going w 3 of things, then stick w it. 3 of these 2 of that and a handful of something else sucked. Apps were so bad we opted out of lunch.