Sheffield's Restaurant - Dyer, Indiana

Sheffield's Restaurant: A Comprehensive Review

Nestled in the heart of Dyer, Indiana, Sheffield's Restaurant, located at 1027 Sheffield Ave, has been a beloved local establishment for years. This versatile venue caters to a wide range of customers, from sports enthusiasts to families, and everyone in between. Let's delve into the details of this popular dining spot.

Main Services

• Restaurant: Sheffield's offers a diverse menu, featuring everything from classic American fare to international cuisine.
• Bar: The well-stocked bar serves a wide array of beverages, including craft beers, premium cocktails, and an extensive wine list.
• Sports Bar: Equipped with numerous TV screens, Sheffield's is a prime location for sports enthusiasts to catch the latest games while enjoying great food and drinks.

Location and Access

Sheffield's Restaurant is situated in the Downtown Dyer area, within walking distance of several other local attractions. The venue is easily accessible, with ample parking space available on-site. For those who prefer public transportation, the Indiana Southern Railway Dyer Station is a short drive away.

Featured Characteristics

• Atmosphere: The restaurant boasts a lively, upbeat atmosphere, with a blend of modern and rustic decor creating a welcoming space for all.
• Outdoor Seating: Sheffield's features a spacious patio area, perfect for alfresco dining on warmer days.
• Wheelchair Accessibility: The restaurant is wheelchair accessible, with features including a designated parking space, wheelchair-accessible entrance, wheelchair-accessible seating, and a wheelchair-accessible toilet.

Practical Information

• Address: 1027 Sheffield Ave, Dyer, IN 46311, United States
• Phone: 2193225808
• Website: sheffieldsrestaurant.com
• Hours: Varies by day, typically opens at 11:00 AM and closes between 10:00 PM and 12:00 AM
• Price Range: $$
• Specialties: Known for their signature burgers and Philly sandwiches, Sheffield's also offers a variety of breakfast options, including omelettes and pancakes.

Customer Reviews

Customers have praised Sheffield's Restaurant for its inviting atmosphere, excellent service, and delicious food. Some notable aspects mentioned in reviews include:

• Great for Parties: Customers have enjoyed hosting events at Sheffield's, citing the spacious venue and ample seating as key factors.
• Delicious Food: Diners have raved about the quality and taste of the food, with particular praise given to the burgers and Philly sandwiches.
• Excellent Service: The friendly and attentive staff has been commended for their professionalism and efficiency.
• Sports Enthusiasts' Paradise: Sports fans have appreciated the numerous TV screens and lively atmosphere for watching games.

While some customers have noted areas for improvement, such as cleanliness and consistency in food quality, the overall consensus is overwhelmingly positive, with an average rating of 4.1/5 stars on Google My Business.

👍 Reviews of Sheffield's Restaurant

Susanna R.

4/5

1st time beeing there. 50th birthday party for my niece, It was the 80's theme good size place. Plenty of tables for the amount of people she had & good size dance floor

April J. (. K.

4/5

We had a great time food was okay. A little on the dirty side could use extra cleaning.

B S.

5/5

Great burgers. Philly was very good as well. Had take out. Will definitely be coming back.

Asha E.

1/5

We just pulled up, with kids in tow. IT IS ONLY A BAR at 2pm on a Sunday. Looks great for drinks but it is not a family friendly restaurant, we were told it’s 21 and asked to go. Nicely asked to leave but not we expected at all; false advertising. The nice lady also said they will be removing restaurant from their website

Morgen B.

3/5

First, the food was amazing. We had a party of six and everyone ordered different food. Not one complaint about the portion sizes, taste, or cost.
The service did leave a little to be desired, however.
The waitress was unfamiliar with the specials and sides. We asked to substitute our son's fries for fruit and were told the price was much higher than printed in the menu (in the end we were charged correctly). Our drinks all ran empty and we had to hunt down someone to refill them.
The floors were sticky all throughout the restaurant and the men's room was disgusting.
Overall we weren't super disappointed, but weren't thrilled either. We'll probably come back again, but I remember this place being much nicer in the past...

Amy C.

5/5

The Banquet room was an excellent venue for a small wedding with family! We had approximately 30 people. The service was impeccable. The banquet room was very tastefully decorated and super clean. Walls, carpets and ceiling all in perfect condition and these are things I strangely look at when I walk into a venue because it demonstrates care and concern to details. It was also quite spacious. The food was just amazing. The chicken Alfredo was good enough for seconds, and everyone at our table raved about it. Everything about our experience was five star. Even the flexibility of the management when it came to using the room for set up was just above and beyond and super appreciated. We will recommend the banquet room for anyone planning a special party and needing a private room. We will surely be back the next time our family has an event.

Mike F.

5/5

Tried the lemon rice soup for lunch. Was delicious came with bread too.. will definitely be back..

Tracey S.

5/5

The wings are amazing. I had the cream of mushroom soup it's the best I've had in a long time. Our server was prompt our water was never empty and the prices were very low. The open face Turkey was nice tender and juicy and thick. Will definitely go back for lunch.