Panagiotas Taste of Greece - Shepherdstown, West Virginia

Jessica C.

Stop what you are doing and dine here! Not only was the atmosphere welcoming, sophisticated, and friendly, but the food was phenomenal. We went on a Sheperdstown Ghost Tour and smelt every delicious aroma leaving this place, having us practically drooling while we walked around. We knew we HAD to dine here.
We enjoyed the Greek Meatball and Kalamari (spelling specific to the menu,) appetizers. Out of this world! Their marinara is delicious, and that was some of the largest calamari pieces we had seen, EVER.
My husband enjoyed a traditional gyro, which was incredibly flavorful. My daughter had the children's pasta and sauce (again bringing in that delicious marinara.) I had the Athenian chicken breast with the Greek green beans instead of rice and my goodness! That sweet and salty balsamic, garlic and Grecian herb sauce brought everything to the next level. The portion was also so large I was able to make myself an entire other meal and a little extra out of my plate.
The staff was so friendly, made sure that everything was to our liking, attentive, and outgoing. They even sang along to the music and jokingly danced along with one another. Thank you for such a phenomenal dining experience.
Panagiotas brought Greece to our table!

Kimberly M.

We stopped here for lunch because we’ve been seeing a lot about it on social media & it did not disappoint!! We started our meal with an order dolmades which were very good & served with feta & olives. My husband had the stuffed cabbage rolls & I had the moussaka. Both were delicious & seasoned perfectly.

Ken

I’ve been looking for an authentic Greek restaurant around here for years. I’ve finally found one and it’s amazing! The servings are huge and the taste is divine! This will become a regular place for my family to dine out.

Jennifer C.

We had a fantastic dining experience! The restaurant’s beautiful Greek-themed decor made for a delightful atmosphere, and it’s clear they’ve put effort into modernizing the space. Our hostess and server were friendly and attentive, adding to the overall great service.

The food was absolutely delicious, with every dish bursting with flavor and prepared to perfection. It’s also a great spot for families—my kids found plenty of yummy options on the menu, which made the meal even more enjoyable. Highly recommend for a family-friendly meal with excellent service!

Diana P.

Great first time experience! Stopped by for a quick bite so got the gyro. It was so delicious and packed with meat! Paired it with the Greek potatoes, which were different than expected but well seasoned and delicious. Will definitely return to try a few more things!

Brandie S.

Food, service and atmosphere was amazing!! Very quaint & quite for a Tuesday afternoon lunch. I loved how the back of the menu had the origin family story behind the name of the restaurant. Lots of authentic dishes to choose from and I noticed there was a nice selection of adult beverages.

michelle A.

This place is beautiful, the mural on the back wall is incorporated so well into the Decor. The bar ambiance is fantastic, I really enjoyed the mixed drink they made me. Looking forward for them to expand menu ro incorporate more gf options. I give this place two thumbs up! 👍

bobbi H.

Nestled in the heart of Shepherdstown’s historic downtown, this new Greek restaurant, opened by the owners of a local food truck favorite brings authentic family recipes to a cozy, tastefully decorated brick-and-mortar space.
Service was friendly and attentive, though timing could use some refinement. Our entrée arrived too close to our appetizer, and the lack of small plates for the shared saganaki detracted slightly from the otherwise seamless experience.
The atmosphere was warm and inviting, that perfectly suits the charm of Shepherdstown.
For the quality of the meal, and portion sizes. Value is there.
This is a fantastic addition to Shepherdstown’s culinary scene! With a bit more polish on timing, it has the potential to be an all-around standout.

What we ate:
Saganaki: laming greek cheese - check out the fire!
Moussaka: traditional greek casserole dish layered with eggplant, ground meat, tomato sauce, finished with a Béchamel Sauce
Stuffed cabbage
Greek salads

My rating rationale
+1 Service
+1 Food~Taste/flavor/quality
+1 Presentation
+1 Atmosphere/vibe
+1 Value