North Shore Pizza and Subs - Monona, Wisconsin

North Shore Pizza and Subs is a highly-rated pizza restaurant and sandwich shop located at 4503a Monona Dr, Monona, WI 53716. This well-regarded establishment offers specialties in both pizza and sandwiches, and has a strong reputation for its quality offerings. It boasts an impressive 4.6/5 average rating based on 215 reviews on Google My Business.

Features and Amenities

• Curbside pickup
• Delivery
• Takeout
• Dine-in
• Sports
• Lunch
• Dinner
• Solo dining
• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot
• Wheelchair accessible restroom
• Wheelchair accessible seating
• Comfort food
• Quick bite
• Lunch
• Dinner
• Dessert
• Seating
• Restroom
• Casual
• Cozy
• Family-friendly
• Groups
• Accepts reservations
• Credit cards
• Debit cards
• NFC mobile payments
• Credit cards
• Good for kids
• High chairs
• Kids' menu
• Free parking lot
• Free street parking
• Dogs allowed outside

Why You Should Visit

The North Shore Pizza and Subs has been praised for its homemade dishes made with care and love. The roast beef sandwich is particularly noteworthy, as it reminded one customer of the ones served at fast food joints in Boston, MA. The onion rings are described as delicious, similar to those at Culver's. The arcade adds to the fun atmosphere, with skee-ball being a favorite game.

With a variety of options for dining, takeout, and delivery, North Shore Pizza and Subs is a great choice for those looking for quality pizza and sandwiches in the Monona area.

👍 Reviews of North Shore Pizza and Subs

Kristi S.

5/5

Food seems to be made with care and love. The arcade is soooo fun too! (especially Skee-Ball!) Only suggestions are to make/serve homemade ranch. The roast beef sandwich reminded me so much of the ones served at fast food joints in Boston, MA (which I have been craving for years) and the onion rings are just as delicious as Culver's! Definitely worth a visit.

Matt B.

5/5

Stopped in on a recommendation while we were in town for a show choir competition at the high school. What a place! Everything our group ordered - from the pizzas to the subs and gyros - were delicious. And best of all, we got to visit with the owner - a great guy who loves what he does as he brings a bit of Boston to Madison! I just wish I remembered to take pics of our food before we finished it off. So glad we stopped in, thanks for a great meal!

Lunch B.

5/5

You don’t come here for atmosphere. This is the place for the most authentic east coast pizza in Wisconsin. Foldable slices. Perfect sauce. Just enough cheese to make it all the perfect messy delight. Add incredible crust, and the bunch has finally found our go to place for pizza in Madison. If you overlook this hidden gem…shame on you for six weeks!

Kate G.

5/5

We had North Shore Pizza and Subs delivered for lunch. Everything was really good! The pizza is fantastic -- especially the sauce. The French bread pizza is perfection. I haven't had that since I was a teenager, and I figured why not try it. It was definitely a highlight of the meal. It was a big portion of French bread pizza, and the leftovers reheated well in the oven. The curly fries are SEASONED which were so good! The regular fries are battered, which are also good, so I would recommend ordering both kinds if you want fries. The chicken tenders are the wide, flat kind, and they were yummy and came with a good barbeque sauce.

Angela J.

5/5

I finally got to North Shore today for lunch, and I was so amazingly happy with the Steak, Cheese and Onion sandwich. It was just pure cheesy, oniony, and black peppery deliciousness - with good quality meat! For several hours after, my husband just kept saying, "that was such a good sandwich!" And it was worthy of this praise! The curly fries were perfectly fried. The service was great and very friendly! I also enjoy a good arcade, and could easily find myself playing some pinball there... I'll hit this spot up anytime I'm near, for sure!

Gayle R.

5/5

Light tomato sauce, great flavor, crunchy crust and I highly suggest giving them a try. You can eat in for that old school " going for pizza" feel and stay to play in the arcade. Loved it!

Abigail V. D.

5/5

Went late on a Friday night to get calzones, I’m not from this area and they were the first place to pop up on Google when I searched. I’m so glad we went there!!! Amazing calzones, I had cheese and my partner added mushroom and pepperoni to his. Both of us finished them in one sitting. The cashier was very friendly and the atmosphere was cozy and fun, we both really enjoyed our food.

Daven H.

5/5

Opportunity worked out and we decided to try North Shore Pizza and Subs today. It was absolutely the right choice. We tried the special steak pizza - crust was fantastic, great toppings and sauce. We were debating which appetizer to get with it and made a little joke about not having a sampler option on the menu. They put together a sampler of the things we were looking at, and all of those bites were quite tasty as well. And great friendly service from the guys plus the accommodation of the app sampler order. Will definitely visit them again.