Monona Bait & Ice Cream Shop - Monona, Wisconsin

Monona Bait & Ice Cream Shop is a charming local gem located at 4516 Winnequah Rd, Monona, WI 53716. This delightful spot offers a range of specialties, including being an Ice cream shop, Dessert shop, Lunch restaurant, and Sandwich shop. The company is also known for being a Small business with Takeout options, and it boasts a Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Wheelchair accessible entrance, and Wheelchair accessible restroom. Pets are welcome outside, and the Cash-only establishment provides Seating for patrons.

Monona Bait & Ice Cream Shop has earned a stellar reputation with a 4.6/5 average rating on Google My Business, thanks to its 220 reviews. Many customers cherish the homey feel of the shop and appreciate the quality of the ice cream sourced from the UW creamery. Additionally, the nearby park across the street provides a lovely atmosphere for outdoor seating and enjoyment.

👍 Reviews of Monona Bait & Ice Cream Shop

Kent W.

5/5

Many memories made at this little spot...just across the street from a quiet little beach front specially designed for young parents and little kids. Mine aren't so young anymore, but two of them asked to come back to visit for the nostalgia, the beach air, and the Babcock (that's right...and yes they carry Orange Chocolate chip).

Justin J.

5/5

A fun local place to grab ice cream. They get their ice cream from the UW creamery so it’s pretty good. The place has a very homey feel. Across the street is a park with a lot of additional outdoor seating.

Matt S.

4/5

Their chocolate shake was predictably good. The service was good once I was served. And the setting is pleasantly different than the more well known spots that we all know. A bit pricey and cash only (though they have an ATM nearby).

Alan B.

5/5

Very welcoming place, in the perfect location. Employees are very friendly and outgoing, always making sure you’re greeted at arrival and welcoming you in. The ice cream, the shakes, the cheese burgers, everything in that shop is very delicious. The shop gives off antique old-fashion vibes which suits the place very well. Whether you’re swimming in the beach right across the street or taking a bike ride around the lake, it is safe to say this shop will fulfill your sweet tooth, or your hungry belly. Not to mention if you’re fishing across the street, you can stop by for some bait to catch some fish. Very friendly owner as well, always striving to do his best. Employees look like they’re trying their very best all of the time, very hardworking employees. Definitely a hidden gem here in Monona.

Ellen L.

5/5

Great burgers and shakes! Cozy and classic decor. Definitely worth stopping here on a bike ride around the lake.

A B.

5/5

Retro vibes. Perfect summer stop across Schluter Beach. You need to pay extra for chocolate flavored ice cream which wasn't expected but well worth it! The place closes mid fall and reopens late spring.

M1gu3l B.

5/5

There is a large variety of high quality delicious ice cream to choose from. You can never go wrong with a sassy cow or a UW Babcock Hall ice cream, especially on a home made waffle cone. I highly recommend this local shop, especially because of the variety of delicious snacks, ice cream, food, shakes, floats, sodas, subs, etc. This shop is very conveniently located, right in the place where people crave ice cream the most. Employees are always smiling and striving to do their best in serving you in your needs. What’s even better is that it is locally owned and operated. I’ll happily come back for some more ice cream!

Alexander B.

5/5

Great place to have fun at the beach and get ice cream.