Mixed Up Waterside Bar and Grill - Amery, Wisconsin

Ryan G.

Big review incoming for the much awaited “Mixed Up - Waterside”…

Vibe Review: What an upgrade from the previous place! I'm excited to see all the enhancements over the next year. New docks and tables are on the way, and the new chairs are a massive upgrade. Live music and a fun atmosphere are always a priority here. This spot will definitely become a weekly staple.

People Review:
- Liz: The owner of all the Miz Up’s is a straight shooter who knows how to treat her clients and staff. She’s all about providing a great experience, and it will only keep getting better. The vibe is already amazing! Also, love that she picked Tito’s, Windsor, and Bacardi as the rails.
- Jackson: A great server who took excellent care of us. He’s a local on the lake and happy to be working there this summer.

Food Review:
- A+ Walleye Sandwich: The walleye alone was an A++. Massive serving and a crowd favorite in our group.
- A+ Bloody Mary: Will always be a hit for brunch or lunch. Loaded with all the Wisconsin bests
- A+ Jalapeño Burger: Whoa… amazing flavor profile. Thick burger patty with caramelized bacon, cream cheese, and house-made jam.
- Walleye Fingers: Also a great appetizer to share.
- D Lobster Roll: We didn’t expect this on the menu in Amery, and honestly, it’s not needed. It was the only dish we wouldn’t order again, and we won’t miss it if it’s gone.

Recommendation: Can we please add a honey mustard or spicy aioli to the menu as a house-favorite sauce!?

P.S. This review wasn’t influenced by our massive pull-tab winner, but that was a fun bonus 🤘

Reba B.

This has been our weekly date night spot for quite a while now! We love the bartenders and servers, they are always friendly and having fun! Chicken fettuccine is my favorite! 🍻 Can't wait to enjoy the patio this summer. ☀️

Marie K.

A group of three with a reservation on Saturday night. Busy with an ice fishing contest on the lake, but expected that. We had scoped out the menu the Thursday before to make sure there were gluten free options.
The servers on Thursday made sure they knew the correct answers, very willing to help. All three in our group ordered prime rib. We all were disappointed as it was average at best, no special seasoning, flavor, etc.. Au jus was basically beef broth. Servers were very good! Disappointed as I made sure the server knew I was gluten free, yet the dinner was served with dinner roll on the meat. It was so busy, I rolled diced, took the roll the meat, and fortunately was okay. For the amount I wrote a check for, will consider else where in the future. Bummer!

Whitney F.

Went for a Friday night dinner. Staff worked as a team and was so attentive and kind. The food was delicious and it was a great price. Can’t wait to come back this summer.

CC A.

Wanted a quiet place to have lunch on the water on Sunday and this family run place did not disappoint!
Drove from the Twin Cities just to have lunch.
All of our food was great.
Burgers were cooked perfectly, juicy and very filling!
Cheese curds as a side were great.
The WAPO (fish) sandwich was almost too big to finish.
You won't leave hungry that's for sure!
The patio on the lake was nice. Great place for watching fisherman. Saw a couple guys fight to pull a big one right in right in front of us.
We were told they have only owned it for a few years.
Nice to see they are fixing it up. Looks like a fresh coat of paint was coming soon on the inside.
We will certainly be back!

Deb P.

Food was excellent and the service was awesome. The drinks were festive and delicious!

Luann F.

Went with friends on a Thursday night. Food was delicious! Drinks were tasty! Service was great!
Will definitely be back.

Curt W.

Stopped in when traveling through the area based on a recommendation from a friend that grew up in the area and had a steak sandwich and an old fashion which were great.