Mike's Italian Restaurant - Baraboo, Wisconsin

Stephanie R.

Would highly highly recommend eating here!!! Mike the owner has really amazing Italian food we got the fettuccine and spaghetti, tortalinni, meatball sub and I forgot what the desert was called but specially their tortalucci or tortalinni it has Alfredo sauce and red sauce together ahh sooo good 👍 that’s mine and my daughter’s absolute favorite dish. 100/10 Tim was our waitress. He was really nice and funny very welcoming altogether I had a really good birthday and will come again and again. 🥰 there food is so worth it you can thank me later oh and don’t forget to try their desserts too 😍

Erin V.

Cannot say enough about this place. We have nine children, eight of them being boys with hearty appetites. Most of the time they end up still hungry after going out to eat and we end up with a whopping big bill. Mike’s Italian is going to be our new go to. Incredibly reasonable prices for the ridiculously huge and hearty pizzas that were brought out to our table. One of my biggest eaters was only able to eat one slice. Absolutely delicious, best pizza we’ve had in Wisconsin.

The service absolutely blew us away as well. We were lucky enough to get Tim. Tim was an absolute expert on the menu, not only explaining every dish and the specials, but telling us what his personal favorites were and why. His opinions were spot on and we were super pleased with our choices. Tim’s timing was fantastic as he came by often to check on us for refills and any additional requests. He was patient and very accommodating.

We will definitely become regulars here.

Farmn

We are absolutely in aw with the wonderful food and service we received tonight ! Ample portions and very unique true Italian food and seasonings. Highly recommend to everyone ! So excited our hometown Baraboo has such a wonderful restaurant!

Alexandria P.

The food was pretty good.
Service was absolutely wonderful. Server was kind , friendly and attentive. Mike himself was incredible. He greeted our table, so lovely of him to do. Atmosphere is welcoming. You're acknowledged right away with kindness. All around a wonderful experience for my family and I.

Dr. J. C.

I always have the same thing 😉. Meat stromboli.
Why do I get the same thing? Because it's awesome.
You know that time you ordered cashew chicken at the Chinese take-out and you usually have general tso chicken and then you have disappointment?
Just get the meat stromboli. It's $13.95, baked to perfection and could be 2 and sometimes 3 meals.
The wait staff is super attentive and keep your water topped off.
Let's talk about Mike. This guy always stops by the table and greets you and asks how things are going. I have never had a bad meal at Mike's Italian Restaurant.
See you there.

Denielle E.

We loved it here. When we arrived there was a strings group rehearsing in a room, so the music was great.

The chef greeted us on the way in. They were understaffed, but the young guy who waited on us was so cheerful and exuded happiness. He was very overwhelmed but oh my gosh, he had us laughing our butt's off!!!

We all agreed this was the best food we have had in ages! We plan to visit again next time we are in the Dells!!!

P.S. I haven't had Fettuccine Alfredo that good years!!!

Vladimira G.

This place is amazing! The food is super delicious, everything is made from scratch and you can tell. Our server was nice and attentive, the chef came to talk to us - very nice guy as well. Thank you this is definitely our new spot. Prices are great too.

Mary H.

We went to Mike’s to celebrate my mother’s 92 birthday. The food was flavors were spot on and excellent! I love the sauces and all our dishes! Mike came out to greet us at our table who is the owner and chef. So friendly and gracious. We’re Italian and loved speaking with him. Service was excellent!