Martino's Pizza of Elmont - Elmont, New York

Martino’s Pizza of Elmont: A Local Favorite

Martino’s Pizza of Elmont is a cherished pizza restaurant located in the heart of Elmont, New York. Situated at 1411 Hempstead Turnpike, this family-owned establishment has cultivated a strong reputation for delivering delicious, authentic Italian-American cuisine and a welcoming atmosphere. With a vibrant history and a commitment to quality, Martino’s has become a staple within the community, consistently drawing customers seeking a satisfying meal and a friendly experience.

Location and Contact Information

The restaurant’s address is 1411 Hempstead Turnpike, Elmont, NY 11003, United States. For those wishing to contact Martino’s directly, the phone number is 516-352-5463. A detailed website, martinosofelmont.net, provides further information, including the menu, hours of operation, and online ordering options. It’s easily accessible with ample free parking lot and on-site parking, ensuring a hassle-free visit.

Dining Options and Amenities

Martino’s offers a diverse range of dining options to suit various preferences. Guests can enjoy a traditional dine-in experience, savor the convenience of delivery and takeaway, or take advantage of no-contact delivery for a safe and contactless meal. The restaurant caters to both casual gatherings and larger parties, with tables available and reservations accepted. A dedicated kids’ menu guarantees that younger diners will find something they love, and high chairs are readily available. The establishment also prides itself on its commitment to accessibility, featuring a wheelchair-accessible car park, wheelchair-accessible entrance, wheelchair-accessible seating, and a wheelchair-accessible toilet, ensuring inclusivity for all patrons.

Menu Highlights and Specialties

While Martino’s is primarily a pizza restaurant, their menu extends beyond just pies. They offer a selection of comfort food classics, including appetizers such as a delightful bread basket – a tempting sampling of pizzas and garlic knots that has garnered significant praise. Guests can also indulge in a variety of small plates and desserts to complete their meal. A wide array of beverages is available, encompassing wine, beer, and coffee. They frequently provide lunch and dinner options, catering to diverse schedules. Furthermore, catering services are available for special events, allowing customers to enjoy Martino’s delicious food at home or at their venue.

Customer Feedback and Atmosphere

Martino’s enjoys overwhelmingly positive feedback from its clientele, with a remarkable 355 reviews on Google My Business. The average opinion stands at 4.4 out of 5 stars, reflecting the restaurant’s dedication to quality and customer satisfaction. Many patrons highlight the family-owned and family-run nature of the business, noting the friendly and welcoming atmosphere. Several reviewers specifically mention the exceptional quality of the food, citing its delicious taste and consistently high standards. One enthusiastic customer described it as “Family owned, family run. Everybody knows everyone. The food is delicious. We’ve been there twice in three weeks and will be going back today. Check out the bread basket. It’s like a sampling of pizzas and garlic knots I LOVE IT”. The establishment’s ambiance is often described as cosy and casual, making it a perfect spot for solo dining, family friendly outings, and groups. Wi-Fi is available for guests to enjoy, and credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments are all accepted. Table service is provided, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The restaurant even offers free of charge street parking, making it even more convenient for visitors.

Additional Services

• Fast service
• Accepts reservations
• Credit cards
• Debit cards
• NFC mobile payments
• Good for kids

In essence, Martino’s Pizza of Elmont is more than just a pizzeria; it’s a cherished community hub offering exceptional food, friendly service, and a welcoming environment.

👍 Reviews of Martino's Pizza of Elmont

Wendy M.

5/5

Family owned, family run. Everybody knows everyone. The food is delicious. We've been there twice in three weeks and will be going back today. Check out the bread basket. It's like a sampling of pizzas and garlic knots! I LOVE IT!

Wendy M.

5/5

It is definitely a family place. Literally and figuratively. The food is delicious!! Even the bread basket is the best I've had. It's like samples of pizzas that they have there, and of course, regular rolls!! We were there two weekends in a row!! When we pulled up, I said to my husband, "This is where you want to go for Father's Day?" I am glad he did change his mind based on my. We would have really missed out.

Michele F.

1/5

Gave restaurant a second chance after a bad experience I had while dining in the restaurant years ago. Ordered a large pie to be delivered by Slice, the restaurants preferred delivery service. Sat down to eat and my granddaughter pulled a long red hair out of her cheese. Called restaurant, was told rudely they did not deliver anything, if Slice delivery it they tampered with it. No one with red hair works there. I explained the hair was cooked in not laying on top of cheese. He insisted it did not come from his restaurant. Call ended with me saying thanks I will never do business with you, the pizzeria’s response okay good. This is the same poor service I experienced when dining in, they placed our orders at the table next to us, walked away , came back picked up both plates we watched the people pick in. The waiter picked up the plates and put them on our table. First pic shows hair on the box.

sara C.

5/5

I visited here to pick up an order and the customer service was so welcoming and everyone was so nice the place was clean and nice the pizzas looked sooooo good and delicious huge slices and thick pizza with lots of toppings definitely gotta come back here

Karen W.

5/5

A small neighborhood pizzeria with amazing pizza and food. There are price fixed pasta specials for $14.95 Sun-Thursday. Check out my photos below. Breadbasket has pepperoni rolls, broccoli rolls, garlic knots, plain bread and brushetta. Great salad too! Can't beat it for the price.

Jerry H.

5/5

A group of us ate here last night & the food was amazing, the service was excellent
& the portions were fantastic. I would definitely recommend all my family & friends to come eat here.

Dennis M.

5/5

Drove up from Philly for Eagles concert and searched for a good spot for pizza…found Martino’s but decided to get the dinners instead…the specials sounded soo good…and they were both excellent…if I lived nearby I’d be there twice a week! Service was excellent and friendly as well. I left my cc in check folder and waitress came running out to parking lot to hand it to me.

Kevin C.

5/5

The best Italian restaurant on LI. The place is simple and the food is 100.% always perfect. Always super fresh and impossible to finish in one sitting. I’ve seen fat people take a doggie bag🙏

Wendy M.

5/5

Family owned, family run. Everybody knows everyone. The food is delicious. We've been there twice in three weeks and will be going back today. Check out the bread basket. It's like a sampling of pizzas and garlic knots! I LOVE IT!

Wendy M.

5/5

It is definitely a family place. Literally and figuratively. The food is delicious!! Even the bread basket is the best I've had. It's like samples of pizzas that they have there, and of course, regular rolls!! We were there two weekends in a row!! When we pulled up, I said to my husband, "This is where you want to go for Father's Day?" I am glad he did change his mind based on my. We would have really missed out.

Michele F.

1/5

Gave restaurant a second chance after a bad experience I had while dining in the restaurant years ago. Ordered a large pie to be delivered by Slice, the restaurants preferred delivery service. Sat down to eat and my granddaughter pulled a long red hair out of her cheese. Called restaurant, was told rudely they did not deliver anything, if Slice delivery it they tampered with it. No one with red hair works there. I explained the hair was cooked in not laying on top of cheese. He insisted it did not come from his restaurant. Call ended with me saying thanks I will never do business with you, the pizzeria’s response okay good. This is the same poor service I experienced when dining in, they placed our orders at the table next to us, walked away , came back picked up both plates we watched the people pick in. The waiter picked up the plates and put them on our table. First pic shows hair on the box.

sara C.

5/5

I visited here to pick up an order and the customer service was so welcoming and everyone was so nice the place was clean and nice the pizzas looked sooooo good and delicious huge slices and thick pizza with lots of toppings definitely gotta come back here

Karen W.

5/5

A small neighborhood pizzeria with amazing pizza and food. There are price fixed pasta specials for $14.95 Sun-Thursday. Check out my photos below. Breadbasket has pepperoni rolls, broccoli rolls, garlic knots, plain bread and brushetta. Great salad too! Can't beat it for the price.