Maggie's Pub - Fayetteville, West Virginia

Kimberly C.

A locals hangout where they even treat the out-of-towners like locals. Josh, owner and bartender, was fantastic - personable, attentive, and incredibly helpful! Be sure to spend a little time with Mayor Norm; he'll warm the heart of even the coldest.

Rhonda E. B.

Have now visited this place multiple times and sure to return anytime we’re in the area. Love the vibe. Great service. Super laid back and sometimes you’ll even catch live music. There’s some board games, darts nice outdoor hang space.

Don J.

Great little local watering hole. Stopped in here the other evening with family and friends for a few beers and a game or two of darts. The gas fireplace out back was a nice touch for a chilly early spring night. Norman, the resident feline, was on hand for a scratch behind the ears (Norman's... not the patrons). If you like staying late, Maggie's is the place. We left and went back to D & M's residence in Fayetteville around midnight. I hung around a while and decided to head back north to home. When I drove by Maggie's there were still a few cars out front. Those were some serious partyers. I was surprised that Maggie's wasn't pinned on Google Maps... so I pinned it !!!

gabriel M.

10/10 the drinks are awesome! Heavy handed on the liquor but perfect balance in the cocktails and I got to pet the cat 🙂

Zayda G. Z.

I recently visited and was quite disappointed with the customer service, specifically from one of the bartenders. On the evening of October 29 2023, I encountered a situation that left me feeling unwelcome and frustrated.

The bartender in question displayed dismissive behavior throughout my visit. When I asked questions about the drink menu, I received short, unhelpful answers, which made me feel like I was inconveniencing them. Furthermore, there was a derogatory comment made that was entirely uncalled for. This type of attitude and behavior should not be tolerated in any establishment.
I requested a Mexican mule and I got a simple cup with lime and tequila.

I hope that The owner takes this feedback seriously and invests in staff training to ensure that all customers are treated with respect and courtesy. It's essential to remember that customer service plays a significant role in the overall experience.

I hope my feedback is helpful in improving the overall experience for future patrons.

Matthew W.

My friends and I discovered this hidden local gem and started our rafting weekend here. Laid back, great staff and robust beer selection.

Kevin B.

If you are a tourist or even a local I would be careful going here and using a credit card. My wife an I were recommended this place by a waitress from another establishment, so we went here and bought two drinks for $18. I left the bartender a $3 dollar tip; thus, making the bill $21 dollars. A day or two later when the transaction posted, it was changed to $38. I can only assume the bartender decided to give herself a tip boost on my dime. The owner should really look into who they have working for them. This kind of behavior is unacceptable and illegal.

Ben

Maggie's was pretty fun actually. It's super confined inside, but what it lacks inside, makes up for with the outside seating area. The outside was really open and great. There's bongos, TV, tambourine, and a friendly cat if you can get him to come to you. Once you make friends with him he loves his belly rubbed 🤠

Drinks were awesome I forget the bartender's name but she made a super great old fashioned. There's no cherry in it, which was a bummer, but they put in a local maple syrup and it really made the drink smooth.

Nice place to chill and kill some time👌🏽 recommend for a cool little hangout.