Good Fellows Baking Co. - Morgantown, West Virginia

Jaime B.

The cookie cake we ordered for our daughter’s 21st birthday was decorated beautifully, but the actual cookie was very dry and did not appear to be very fresh. No one at the party ate their piece. It was a very special occasion and the cake was a huge disappointment.

Liz P.

Been here a few times and everything has been really good. Very friendly service too ☺️ I love that I can get a fresh breakfast sandwich just about any time of day! Their egg & cheese on a bagel is 👌 Their desserts are delicious & not too sweet. Also love the mini focaccias.

jean-philippe C.

Looking for a quick lunch I stopped at Good Fellows Baking and was happily surprised. The chicken salad was great and the pastries were delicious. The price is reasonable, I will go back.

R S.

Their cakes are delicious and special! This was the lemon/blueberry with mascarpone icing:).

Ingrid P.

Ordered a custom cake for my boyfriend's birthday. While the cake was delicious, I can't help but feel as though I was a little cheaped out for the amount I paid.
I had sent them a few inspiration photos, all of which contained a 3-dimensional guitar decoration on top of the cake. I asked that the cake look similar to those photos... with a guitar decoration and musical notes on it like in the photos. Whether that guitar topping would've been made of candy, plastic, fondant, or something else, I would have been happy with it. When I got the cake, it only had a flat print out of a guitar on it. Albeit I didn't explicitly ask for a 3D guitar decoration, but then again, every photo I had sent to them contained an obvious three-dimensional mini model guitar decoration... Not to mention the amount I paid for this cake.
Generally speaking, the cake I received looked a tad sad without the guitar decoration I had hoped for. I liked the frosting design and little gold pebbles, but for a small 9' cake, I expected more for having spent over $70 on the darn thing.

Ignore the smudged/slid over side of the cake.. that happened during transport and was not a fault of the bakery!

Edit: They reached out to me and were real kind about it. She says she would've done a better guitar decoration had she known it was that important. They were super generous and gave a pretty hefty partial refund.

Luanne S.

I've ordered cupcakes twice and a birthday cake. They were absolutely deicious!! I've also tried the chicken tortilla soup and ham+bean soup, sooo good!! Jaclyn is really nice and does a beautiful job decorating the cakes

Sierra C.

Ordered a cake for my daughter’s 2nd birthday and it turned out perfect! Such a cute cake and everyone at the party agreed that it was DELICIOUS 😋

Tamara R.

I ordered a lemon blueberry marscarpone cake for my husband as part of his Father's Day present. It was beautiful and tasted amazing. It's now my husband's favorite cake! For Mother' Day, my husband bought me a giant lemon blueberry cupcake with lemon curd filling and it was delicious! The homemade lemon curd tasted amazing, but the icing really blew it out of the water. Definitely my favorite icing ever! We've also purchased muffins and churro cookies as well. We've never been disappointed and everything is always beautifully done. This will be our go to from now on for all of our cake and pastry needs!