Firehouse Bakery & Deli / Hayward Bakery & Cheese Shop - Hayward, Wisconsin

Firehouse Bakery & Deli: A Local Gem in Hayward, Wisconsin

For those seeking a delightful experience centered around freshly baked goods and quality deli items, Firehouse Bakery & Deli / Hayward Bakery & Cheese Shop stands as a premier destination. Located at 10565 Main St, Hayward, WI 54843, this establishment has quickly become a beloved fixture within the community. With a readily accessible phone number, 7156342428, and a strong online presence – though currently lacking a dedicated website – customers can easily connect with the bakery and explore its offerings.

Specialties and Culinary Delights

The core of Firehouse Bakery & Deli’s appeal lies in its Specialties: Bakery. They are renowned for a remarkable variety of baked goods, crafted with attention to detail and utilizing high-quality ingredients. Customers frequently rave about their scones, noting their delightful texture and flavor profiles. However, the grilled ham & cheese sandwiches, particularly those featuring their sourdough bread, are consistently highlighted as a standout item – a testament to their dedication to traditional baking techniques and delicious combinations. Beyond the classics, the bakery offers a rotating selection of pastries, cakes, and other sweet treats, ensuring there’s something to satisfy every craving. The deli component complements the bakery perfectly, providing a selection of meats, cheeses, and accompaniments for creating custom sandwiches and platters.

Key Features and Services

Firehouse Bakery & Deli prioritizes convenience and accessibility for its patrons. They offer a range of services including In-store pick-up, allowing customers to conveniently collect their orders. Takeaway is readily available, perfect for enjoying a treat on the go. For those needing items delivered, Same-day delivery is offered, significantly expanding their reach. The bakery is committed to inclusivity, boasting a Wheelchair-accessible car park and a Wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that everyone can easily access their products and services. The establishment also accepts a variety of payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and convenient NFC mobile payments, streamlining the checkout process.

Operational Details and Customer Feedback

Firehouse Bakery & Deli operates with a focus on speed and efficiency, offering a Quick visit option for those seeking a rapid service. The consistently positive reception reflected in the Average opinion: 4.3/5 rating on Google My Business underscores the high quality of their products and service. With a remarkable 169 reviews, a significant portion of which praise the friendly staff and delicious food, the bakery has cultivated a loyal customer base. The overwhelmingly positive feedback suggests a strong commitment to customer satisfaction, evident in the interactions with staff such as Katie, who is frequently mentioned for her helpfulness and friendly demeanor – as evidenced by reviews like, “5 stars all around 🙌 Katie was so friendly and a great help in finding the perfect treats We love the scones and the sour dough made for the BEST grilled ham & cheese Couldn’t recommend more”.

Location and Contact Information

The bakery’s location at 10565 Main St, Hayward, WI 54843 provides easy access for residents and visitors alike. The phone number, 7156342428, provides a direct line for inquiries and order placement. While a website is currently unavailable, potential customers can easily find the bakery’s location and contact details through online search engines and mapping services. The combination of a welcoming atmosphere, high-quality products, and convenient services makes Firehouse Bakery & Deli a valuable addition to the Hayward area.

Further considerations include:

• Fresh Ingredients: Emphasis on using fresh, locally sourced ingredients whenever possible contributes to the superior taste of their baked goods.
• Custom Orders: The bakery welcomes custom cake and dessert orders for special occasions, showcasing their flexible and accommodating approach.
• Community Focus: Firehouse Bakery & Deli appears to be deeply embedded in the local community, fostering relationships with customers and contributing to the area’s vibrant atmosphere.

In conclusion, Firehouse Bakery & Deli / Hayward Bakery & Cheese Shop presents a compelling option for individuals seeking delectable baked goods, quality deli items, and a welcoming local experience. Their commitment to customer satisfaction, combined with their convenient services and prime location, positions them as a valued asset within the Hayward community.

👍 Reviews of Firehouse Bakery & Deli / Hayward Bakery & Cheese Shop

Emily

5/5

5 stars all around 🙌 Katie was so friendly and a great help in finding the perfect treats! We love the scones and the sour dough made for the BEST grilled ham & cheese! Couldn’t recommend more!

Sydney W.

5/5

This place truly deserves five stars. The staff was incredible, with great conversation. The pastries all looked amazing and I had a hard time choosing. I settled for a raspberry croissant and caramel pecan croissant, both were incredible! I will be going back tomorrow for multiple fresh bread loaves and pastries before heading home. Apparently, the loaves freeze well and I will be taking that recommendation. (Update: I went again the day after, and the pastries are amazing! I absolutely love the chocolate hazelnut croissant and blackberry fans!)

Marion S. J.

3/5

Nice bakery, good selection. Everything looked really good, but the scones did not have much flavor and the almond pastry were to rich. We did not get our receipt when we walked out and noticed we were about $6.00 overcharged. We went back in right after we noticed. They did do right by us and corrected their mistake. Everyone was very friendly.

Bette B.

5/5

As an out-of-town visitor today who happens to be very picky about bakeries, I was delighted to find such a beautiful array of highest-quality breads and pastries! The Ancient Grains loaf was still fresh and warm from the oven, and the baker/host thoughtfully packaged it for my journey. The apple oatmeal cookie I selected to eat in the car was to die-for. I will for sure return to Firehouse Bakery!

Stacy W.

5/5

Wonderful variety of bakery items. The almonds claws are incredible! We happened to get them as they were coming out of the oven, which made them even better! The chocolate hazelnut filled croissant was good as well. I ordered a cinnamon croissant, which looks like a cinnamon roll, and was told it is one of the best things they have, but I have not tried it yet. This is a place that people go on a regular basis because they know the quality they are getting. I saw people coming out with multiple loaves of bread. The service was wonderful and the line moves fast.

chuck B.

5/5

Great bakery and just the best sour dough bread anywhere!!. Lots of choices, peasant and jalapeño-cheddar are off the charts

Jennifer M.

5/5

I ordered 2 Dozen Guinea pig cookies, they were a hit with the adults and the kids. My niece loved them sooo much, she started off by saying noone could eat any. Lol

Dakota B.

3/5

We received a wedding cake from Firehouse bakery. It was very delicious but had two problems. One was they forgot one tier was supposed to be a different flavor, but remembered in time to bake a whole other tier to correct it with no extra charge, so they did fix this mistake. The other was the decoration was not really up to my expectations. She did say she had never done birch tree style before, but I wish she would have recommended another style if she wasn't confident in her ability to pull the birch off. I have included the cake I was hoping it to look like and what ours looked like. Very good cake, sub-par decorating.