DiCarlo's Pizza - Wheeling - Wheeling, West Virginia

Located at 1311 Main St, Wheeling, WV 26003, United States, DiCarlo's Pizza - Wheeling is a renowned pizza restaurant offering a wide range of specialties including pizza delivery and takeaway. With a 4.4/5 average rating on Google My Business, this establishment has received 1127 reviews.

Services and Features

• Pizza restaurant
• Fast food restaurant
• Pizza delivery
• Pizza takeaway

Additional Information

• No-contact delivery
• Delivery
• Takeaway
• Dine-in
• Lunch
• Dinner
• Solo dining
• Wheelchair-accessible car park
• Wheelchair-accessible entrance
• Wheelchair-accessible seating
• Alcohol
• Beer
• Comfort food
• Late-night food
• Quick bite
• Small plates
• Lunch
• Dinner
• Seating
• Toilet
• Casual
• Historic
• Trendy
• Groups
• Tourists
• University students
• Accepts reservations
• Credit cards
• Debit cards
• NFC mobile payments
• Credit cards
• Good for kids
• High chairs
• Kids' menu
• Free of charge street parking
• Free parking lot
• Parking

The restaurant is renowned for its unique style of pizza, with great service and ordering at the counter. The pizza is served in boxes, and there's plenty of parking available. Customers appreciate the good value for delicious pizza, while some enjoy the crunch of the crust and the freshness of the grated cheese served cold on top.

Feedback

One customer remarked, 'Classic pizza shop with a unique style of pizza. Great service ordering at the counter with the pizza served in boxes. Plenty of parking in the lot or on the side of the street out front. Good value for delicious pizza. The crunch of the crust is so satisfying as is the freshness of the grated cheese served cold on top.'

Others have mentioned that the sauce is tasty and the dough is pretty good. However, some might find the non-melted cheese on top less appealing.

👍 Reviews of DiCarlo's Pizza - Wheeling

Joe T.

5/5

Classic pizza shop with a unique style of pizza. Great service ordering at the counter with the pizza served in boxes. Plenty of parking in the lot or on the side of the street out front. Good value for delicious pizza. The crunch of the crust is so satisfying as is the freshness of the grated cheese served cold on top.

Justin V.

3/5

Sauce was tasty and dough were pretty good. Non-melted cheese is not my preference. Might be good for other, just not great for me.

Kaylin M.

5/5

Fantastic pizza!! similar to a place at home, but thinner and more of a crunch!
Fantastic spot.
If you go at lunch, order ahead. I waited 20-25 minutes for 3 slices, plain.
I'm glad they dont use too much sauce, the crunchy crust and the cold cheese are the stars!!

Eric C.

5/5

Finally got the chane to check out the legendary DiCarlo's! I really enjoyed the 3 slice combo, & the kids loved rhe pepperoni rolls. I am a fan of the Ohio Valley Style pizza that we get closer to home at Beato's. Comparitvely, Dicarlo's has a smoother sauce with more thang, and a thinner crispier crust. I think the aize of the cut is a bit smaller than Beato's. Both are delicious if you're in the mood for Ohio Valley Style pie!

Ken C.

5/5

The best! If you like a stewed tomato sauce and a cold cheese approach, you won’t be disappointed. The can cook down the cheese if you want, but I don’t suggest against their signature pizza. Cheers!

Dave T.

5/5

This Wheeling original is still going strong. I’m not really a pizza fan, but something about the cold provolone that goes on after cooking really works for me.

Lisa

2/5

Pizza was good but doesn’t seem like a good place to work. I was there a week ago when I’m assuming it was the manager screamed at and fired an employee right in lobby infront of customers and staff. Not very professional in my opinion. Not how you manage people I’m sorry.

Jeff C.

5/5

First time trying this style of pizza. Was pleasantly surprised. The store was clean, and the staff overall was friendly once I was acknowledged and taken care of. Not sure why I had to wait so long when I called ahead.