Crumbl - Pleasant Prairie - Pleasant Prairie, Wisconsin

Travis (.

Crumbl Cookies Pumpkin Square: New for 2024 from Crumbl is the Pumpkin Square. It's advertised as "a moist, fluffy pumpkin square marbled with brown sugar cinnamon butter, smothered with a light vanilla cream cheese frosting, and topped with a sprinkle of warm spice". I almost didn't buy this because it was my first "square" from Crumbl and I didn't know if it would be worth the price tag or not (an additional dollar to their already questionable base price). For starters, it is relatively large and heavy. Cutting a piece out of the tray, it was even thicker than it initially appeared. Even though it's thick, I found it to be somewhat light and airy/fluffy. Its texture is a cross between cake and pumpkin pie. Sort of hard to imagine, it's a cake, but a little gooey like pumpkin pie. The square is intended to be served warm and when done so, it practically melts in your mouth. As for the flavor, it's a mild pumpkin with hints of cinnamon without too much spice or burning. I feared there might not have been enough cream cheese frosting since the layer on top is thinner than a skeleton, but the intense sweetness of it more than makes up for the amount. Hidden by the cream cheese is a layer of gooey brown sugar cinnamon butter that also ups the sweetness. I looked like the quintessential jack-o'-lantern after eating my pumpkin square as I had a larger-than-life grin on my face. Doughboy approved
Doughboy_Food_Reviews
My Top Crumbl Cookies:
1. Caramel Popcorn
2. Salted Caramel Cheesecake
3. Blue Monster
4. Cake Batter/Birthday Cake
5. Mallow Sandwich ft. OREO
*Pumpkin Square (favorite non-cookie from Crumbl)

Steve R.

Updated Review - 11/21/24: A vendor brought by some Crumbl cookies to the office today. They were delicious! I shared them with the people at work. They all loved them too! I highly recommend everything from Crumbl… 😃
————
Original Review: There is nothing like Crumbl Cookies. Number one, they are huge. Number two, they are delicious. Number three, there is no way you eat one and say it wasn't delicious. I think I have tried every flavor. My favorite is the one with the white frosting and fruit on top. (I pretend it is really good for me because it has fruit on the top.) I highly recommend Crumbl Cookies!

Ariana F.

The store was so neat and clean. When I walked in It smelled amazing and I could see my cookies being freshly made. Amazing service and the cookies are just outstanding. 5 stars!!!

Meg T.

Very nice place! I only go once in a while but my last trip was so much fun. I got the carrot cake cookie (which I love carrot cake so was very excited) and it was so moist and just so amazing.

Jeremy E.

I just honestly don't get the obsession. That's just my personal stance. You can make a couple dozen homemade chocolate chip cookies for the price of one of these. Just not my jam. I don't think a cookie should cost as much as a meal, especially in 2025

Julie O.

I ordered these cookies from Crumbl for a co-workers last day of work. I ordered at the last minute. The cookies arrived less than an hour after ordering. Upon opening the box, a wonderful smell wafted up...delicious. The cookies looked wonderful and everyone could not wait for a taste. Crumbl cookies are definitely fabulous. Every one that we ordered tasted exquisite.

Deplorable R.

Don't know what it is about munching on a Crumbl cookie but whenever I stop at any location, my boys who are 3 and 8 years old come to mind but I always end up getting 1 or 2 for myself.

This taste is irresistible and the person/people behind the idea of rotating 5 out of 6 flavors every week is pure genius. The world's best cookie bakery?......perhaps.

That soft, moist, delicious mouthwatering, practicallly melt in your mouth sensation when you bite into one of these is an experience like no other cookie out there.

Pricey?.......Indeed but worth it. The high end cookie brand is sooo difficult to pass up from time to time whenever I get that craving. I hope to see locations continue to pop up all over the US and many other countries around the world.

Alexi L.

We used Crumbl minis for our wedding reception back in August and they were a huge hit! No cookie was spared and everyone loved them. We were even able to use our original wedding cake flavor, red velvet, as one of the Cookie flavors! Overall, would recommend them for any future couple looking for something different and delicious!