Caken' Me Crazy - Hayward, Wisconsin

McKenna

I wanted so badly to give this place 5 stars.

My husband and I got married in October and had our cake and cupcakes made here. The cupcakes were great and they delivered to our venue which was an hour away, so we’re grateful for that!

Thankfully we didn’t notice the day of our wedding, but our cake was supposed to have raspberry filling (which we paid for) and it didn’t. We put our cake in a deep freezer and continued to eat it for a couple months after our wedding, so that’s when we noticed. I was pretty disappointed because I remember trying a raspberry filled cupcake and being so excited to add that to our cake.

So be sure to triple check the kind of cake they’re making if you order for your wedding.

Matthew

We got our wedding cake and cupcakes here and just wow. They tasted amazing, looked fantastic, and were everything we wanted. It was so nice to be able to come in and sample things, and work with them to get exactly the look we wanted. Would absolutely recommend.

Tale B. ?.

We ordered our wedding cake from Cake'n Me Crazy and it was not only stunning, but tasted delicious! There was barely any left at the end of the night. We did all our communication remote, and I had sent some inspo photos. Stacy was very responsive, and was also able to deliver the cake to our wedding per my last minute request. The cake was way bigger and more beautiful than I had imagined! It was my dream wedding cake. Highly recommend this bakery for any events!

Cassandra W.

Amazing cakes always made to order! Ordered a few things for a birthday party and, as always, everything was fabulous. Definitely going to be ordering from here again. Staff is wonderful, going above and beyond, plus being patient with me having zero input from the birthday boy on decorations for the cake.

Andrea O.

I was so pleased with our Nightmare Before Christmas themed wedding cake. Stunning decor, delicious and moist. We had the marble with raspberry filling and sweet buttercream. Thee best cake I have ever had and it truly put the finishing touch on our special day! Thank you to Stacy and your team!

Van K.

My wife ordered these wonderful cupcakes for my surprise birthday party. They were very delicious, and beautifully decorated.

Tiffaney L.

My sister in law ordered two cakes for a birthday and graduation, both were amazing! Nice and moist and great flavor!! Will definitely be ordering again and we did! Ordered my wedding cake and gluten free cupcakes for my wedding. All were amazing. My friend who had the GF cupcakes said they were some of the best she’s ever had.

Nancy M.

We ordered a sheet cake for my mother's 90th birthday party and were SO happy with it! The chocolate cake was moist and flavorful and the decoration was exactly what we wanted. They also provided some gluten-free cupcakes that were amazing and decorated in the same theme. My husband owned a bakery for 30 years and was VERY impressed by both the quality of the product and the execution of the decorating. We highly recommend this bakery!