Pizza Athena - Palmer, Alaska

Kine N.

Looked forward to trying their santorini wrap, unfortunately one bite was enough. Nothing but cheese and tasteless canned vegetables. No flavor whatsoever. Not sure what we paid for.. pizza was better, generous size. Flavor overall lacking.

Jennifer C.

My son and I were so delighted to stumble across this delightful little pizzeria!!! Lucky for us they were rude to us @ the Hatcher Pass Lodge, and we ambled on down the road until we came across this gem of a place to eat. The owner and staff were all very courteous and accommodating when it came to ordering a specialty pizza! The pizza was AMAZING!!! 🤩 Highly Recommend this establishment!!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Elizabeth R.

Order was incorrect on the pizza as well as overcooked and the fries were over seasoned and so salty very dissatisfied with the food

Shania B.

$55 and we still had to cook dinner at home. Bummed because I like pizza Athena, but the chicken gyros are a waste of money if they’re not made into a meal right. We ordered 3 (because we know they’re small) tonight we opened our boxes after ordering their delicious potato salad and we got bagged chips.. our gyros were so dry they fell apart while eating, the chicken was so dry I could hardly chew it (each gyro barely came with 3 small pieces of chicken) and they were stone cold. Heated mine up a bit.
$16/ea and you get a small fall apart gyro and a bag of chips..

To add, other times they’ve forgotten our soda, extra sauces. People need to understand we aren’t just another customer to get over with, our dinner matters and so does our hard earned income.

So we’re cooking dinner.

Im not posting this to detour people, I want the owner to see the disappointment and maybe fix a few things they might not be aware of.

Jacob V.

We stopped here on our way back to Anchorage from Hatchers Pass and it was super good! We were provided quick and courteous service and the pizza and cheesy bread we had were delicious. Whether you're local to the area or just passing through or visiting, this is a great place to eat.

Juli B.

We ordered two pizzas, both were supposed to be thick crust and neither are. They also forgot to deliver our soda. When I called I was told that to get a refund on the soda I would need to contact a third party, which is fine, but as I was explaining the crust situation either our call got disconnected or the clerk hung up on me. This was my first time ordering from Pizza Athena and I won’t order again.

Update: I contacted Slice about this issue and received this response: “ the shop informed me that you got a thick-crust pizza they made a medium pizza so its a thick crust and they used two doughs to make the pizza”

What 😂😂😂 I ordered two small pizzas with thick crust and received two small pizzas with regular crust. What are they even talking about?

Also, I realized I didn’t actually review the pizza quality. It’s mediocre. Definitely not worth dealing with the subpar customer service.

katarina L.

They canceled my order twice and said they wouldn’t deliver to Wasilla. I’m 15 mins away from them and only about ten miles. They also said they were closing at 8pm but online it said their hours were till 10pm. Very disappointed.

Brittany S.

Fantastic lunch! Office ordered lunch, I got the Athena Meat Sub Wrap. I can not recommend it enough! Great flavors, great layers, great side dressing!