Whisk Café Keystone Heights - Keystone Heights, Florida

Anne S.

March 2025
This place is so clean and well kept. Staff is professional. There are gluten-free options on the menu. We have enjoyed several varieties of sandwiches and salads, all prepared well. The spicy buffalo wings are not actually that spicy. There are growing pains. This restaurant has only been open a few weeks in our small town. However, most of my experiences have always been positive with the taste and food.
The young workers inside the store are extremely kind and helpful. Every time there has been an issue with an order or misunderstanding the special requests, they have kindly accommodated.
One recurring issue is that the tapioca pearls in the boba teas are often undercooked. Almost every time we go, we order boba tea and I am sure this will get better as the weeks progress.

Jeffrey S.

Was super excited to try the Whisk Cafe after reviews and photos I’ve seen on Google and Facebook. However the hype I saw online was false in both mine and my wife’s opinion. I got the Cajun Turkey Club as well as the 1905 Salad from the Pick 2 option. My wife got the Pesto Chicken and a 1905 salad. Well neither half sandwiches had any dressing. Both sandwiches are named for the dressing of them. There was no pesto in site on the Pesto Chicken sandwich at all if there happened to be some it was a pea sized drop. The menu said shredded Roast chicken and there was dry sliced chicken or turkey in place of the shredded roasted chicken The Cajun turkey club was named for the Cajun Mayo that was to give it flavor. All there was super soggy toasted sourdough bread, this was what helped the sandwich to be eaten without a gallon of water . The turkey and ham on this sandwich were extremely dry. Never had lunch meat this dry at any sandwich shop. The lettuce and tomato on this sandwich had no hope of helping with how dry the meats were. When pulling apart the sandwich there was so Cajun mayo at all nothing remotely saucy to help moisten your night other than the soggy bread. The 1905 salad which sounds great in description was so bland. It tasted like it was covered in just olive oil. Menu says comes with lemon juice and Worcestershire sauce. There was none of either in existence of this salad both items have their own flavor palettes that are bold but nothing but oil on the bagged salad mix with one tomato wedge and it called for ham and Swiss cheese. Well there was maybe two little pieces between both salads that were ordered. Tried to doctor up the salad but there was so much olive oil there was no way to get added flavor to help. Highly disappointed with what was served compared to high price. The only positive would be the friendly lady at the counter.

Kristina M.

Wow nice savory soup and salad. I got creamy chicken with artichokes with spinach it was delicious! I took some lasagna home for dinner. So happy there is a great place now with soup and sandwiches for lunch.

cheryl B.

Lovely local sandwich & ice cream shop. Seating inside and out.
Sides prepackaged in a cooler. Ice cream flavors written on the wall.

Crystal R.

Absolutely LOVED the food. Big portions for the perfect price. Highly recommend the Cajun club and Buffalo salad. The little lady taking our order was sweet and funny. Loved sitting outside.

Vince C.

Ordered the chicken pesto, Italian sandwich, tomato soup and potato chips.

—Tomatoe bisque was good. Creamy and delicious

—Italian sandwich seemed like it was going to be good. Once we bit into it we realized that the plastic casing was still left on pepperoni when cooked and served. We let the manager know and she checked with the kitchen. They said it’s fine and it’s not plastic. 🤦‍♂️. They made another one and still had the same thing on it. It was plastic. Stuck in your teeth and stretched. Lacking any meat in sandwich. More bread than anything. Didn’t really get to enjoy it. Got refunded and moved on.

Probably some new restaurant bugs to work out. Overall all I think I might try it again in a few months. It might be a whisk though 😂😂

—Chicken pesto was bland. Needed more flavor, more pesto, salt. Chicken was gods but lacking. Barely any on sandwich, needed more roasted red pepper for that taste. Bread was good. Sandwich could have been elevated with some balsamic vinegar reduction or just some on the side.

—Potato chips were over cooked and dark brown. They were ok to good. Seasoning was only on some chips.

Jordan P.

Good food nice staff the renovations make the place look a lot better

Cristal L.

I stopped in and got the Cuban Sandwich and a Greek Salad with Chicken to go. We were quite happy with the freshness, quality and the taste of the items. We are so tired of fast food chains and it great to have a great variety with plenty of healthy options too. We can't wait to try the Pot Pies, Strawberry Popovers and the Boba Teas in the future. The owner and staff are very nice and they want to make the customer happy!