La Oaxaqueña - Geneva, New York

La Oaxaqueña: A Taste of Mexico in Geneva, NY

Nestled at 20 Castle St, Geneva, NY 14456, La Oaxaqueña offers a delightful Mexican dining experience that is both authentic and flavorful.

Specialties and Atmosphere

• Specialties: Mexican restaurant, focusing on traditional dishes with a modern twist.
• Atmosphere: A casual, family-friendly environment that welcomes locals and visitors alike.

Service and Amenities

• Service: Fast and efficient, perfect for those looking for a quick bite or a relaxed meal.
• Amenities: Takeaway, dine-in options, wheelchair-accessible parking, and free street parking.

Customer Reviews

With an Average opinion of 4.8/5 from 39 Google My Business reviews, La Oaxaqueña is highly regarded by its customers. While some patrons mention the friendly atmosphere and excellent service, others praise the food's authenticity and flavor.

However, some customers have noted that the dining environment could be more welcoming, with one reviewer mentioning they felt uncomfortable due to stares from other patrons. Despite this, the food quality remains the standout feature, with many customers raving about the Mexican dishes.

Recommendations

• Try the Mole Poblano or Tacos al Pastor for an authentic Mexican experience.
• Consider visiting during lunch or early dinner hours for a more relaxed atmosphere.
• While credit and debit cards are accepted, it's a good idea to have some cash on hand for gratuity.

👍 Reviews of La Oaxaqueña

Tracie B.

4/5

The food was amazing and very authentic!! The atmosphere left much to be desired. When we walked in we got stares from all in the restaurant, no one greeted us and we were thankful for our daughter who was fluent in Spanish and could read and explain the menu board.
If I only based my thoughts on the food I would definitely go back often, but because of the atmosphere of the patrons I probably will not.

Dario B.

5/5

I came in with no idea what was about to happen.
"Hello, I'd like a burrito, please"
"Beef, chicken, pork"
"Chicken, please"
She then disappeared into the kitchen. A few minutes later, she returns... With this fabulous burrito. Very authentic, fresh ingredients, and cooked perfectly. It's one of the best burritos I've ever had.
My only complaint is that the prices weren't listed, and there was no Mexican music playing! I love to hear the trumpets of Mexico when I visit places like this.

David B.

5/5

Cute little cantina tucked inside this Mexican mini-mart. Great authentic food made from scratch! The horchata was wonderful 👍🏻

Kevin M.

5/5

This spot is fabulous! We ordered three tacos and one huarache, all with al pastor. They came with chips and salsa, and everything was so tasty. I was honestly just so impressed with the variety of ingredients for the huarache and was so full afterward. Excellent quality food, and for a great price, too!

John K.

5/5

An amazing selection of authentic Mexican dishes served fresh. There is also a small store selling mexican specialties like fresh chierezo sausage. Just a great experience with delicious food.

laurie K.

5/5

Wow. Tamales (me) and burrito (husband) were insanely fresh and perfect. Almost passed this up as it looks like a grocery store front. But make no mistake, this place offers great food and friendly people.

Jonathan Q.

5/5

Great find with excellent tacos. Thin tortilla with the right amount of crisp and that doesn’t fall apart. The suadero, asada, and chorizo were flavorful and cooked perfectly.

David L.

4/5

I've been coming here for 8 years, and I'm happy they prettied it up a bit, they're still very friendly and the food is still decent, but since my last visit they took the more exciting options off the menu...