The Village Supper Club - Pleasant Prairie, Wisconsin

The Village Supper Club: A Detailed Recommendation

For those seeking a truly authentic and enjoyable dining experience, The Village Supper Club in Pleasant Prairie, Wisconsin, presents a compelling option. Located at 10909 Sheridan Rd, Pleasant Prairie, WI 53158, United States, this establishment has cultivated a loyal following over the years, consistently delivering high-quality food, a welcoming atmosphere, and an impressive selection of beverages. With a phone number of 2626972847 and a comprehensive website at villagesupperclub.com, planning a visit is straightforward. The Village Supper Club offers a range of services designed to cater to diverse preferences, including delivery, takeaway, dine-in options, and a commitment to accessibility for patrons with mobility challenges.

A Taste of Tradition and Modern Comfort

The Village Supper Club’s core offering is a menu rooted in American cuisine, with a particular emphasis on comfort food classics. However, it’s far from a simple throwback to the past; the kitchen skillfully blends traditional recipes with contemporary techniques, resulting in dishes that are both familiar and exciting. Notable specialties include the ‘Relish Tray,’ a welcome nod to Wisconsin’s rich culinary heritage, and signature items such as the ‘Poor Man’s Lobster & Filet,’ which has garnered considerable praise. The restaurant also consistently features seasonal specials, often showcasing prime rib and inventive salads. The beverage program is equally impressive, boasting a great beer selection, meticulously crafted cocktails, a great wine list, and a selection of coffee for a post-meal treat.

Atmosphere and Amenities

Beyond the food and drinks, The Village Supper Club is renowned for its distinctive ambiance. Guests frequently describe the space as cosy and welcoming, contributing to the establishment’s enduring popularity. The bar area plays a significant role in the overall experience, providing a lively and social hub. The restaurant prioritizes the comfort of its patrons, offering high chairs, ensuring accessibility for families. Furthermore, the establishment is fully wheelchair-accessible, featuring a wheelchair-accessible car park, wheelchair-accessible entrance, wheelchair-accessible seating, and a wheelchair-accessible toilet. Dinner reservations are highly recommended, particularly during peak hours, and the restaurant accepts a variety of payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments. Plenty of free street parking and a free parking lot are also available.

Customer Feedback and Reputation

The Village Supper Club consistently receives positive feedback from its patrons. Currently, the restaurant boasts over 304 reviews on Google My Business, reflecting a significant level of customer engagement. The average opinion is a commendable 4.6/5, indicating a high level of satisfaction across the board. Many patrons highlight the restaurant’s reliability, consistently delivering delicious food and excellent service. The friendly and attentive staff are frequently praised, creating a welcoming and memorable dining experience. The restaurant’s ability to retain customers for an extended period – evidenced by one patron’s comment of “We’ve been coming to The Village for three years now and will only stop when they throw us out” – speaks volumes about its appeal. It's important to note that while one individual’s assessment of bologna sandwiches might be considered unconventional (as highlighted by a specific commenter), the overall consensus overwhelmingly supports the quality and value offered by The Village Supper Club.

Key Features Summary

• Location: 10909 Sheridan Rd, Pleasant Prairie, WI 53158
• Phone: 2626972847
• Website: villagesupperclub.com
• Cuisine: American (Comfort Food)
• Services: Delivery, Takeaway, Dine-in
• Beverages: Great beer selection, Great cocktails, Great wine list, Coffee
• Accessibility: Wheelchair accessible
• Payment Options: Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments

In conclusion, The Village Supper Club offers a delightful dining experience characterized by quality food, a comfortable atmosphere, and exceptional service. It’s a place where guests can reconnect with classic American flavors in a relaxed and inviting setting.

👍 Reviews of The Village Supper Club

Brian G.

5/5

We've been coming to The Village for three years now and will only stop when they throw us out.

The relish tray is a welcoming throw back. The Poor Man's Lobster & Filet are my wife's go-to. The specials, the prime rib, the salads and the cocktails are spot-on every time.
The limited tables and welcoming bar keep us coming back.

Tod M doesn't know what he is talking about, The Village has great food. He gives 5-Stars to bologna sandwiches. Don't listen to him.

Barb

5/5

Sue's homemade cooking is fantastic!! What a lovely staff and impeccable service. Thank you Jason for seating us on a hectic Valentine night and lucky for us someone cancelled!! We love this Supper Club. Everything fresh delicious and home made. Thank you Sue for a lovely evening!
Barb and John

D A.

4/5

Friday dinner for the four of us consisted of walleye, catfish and fish tacos - all dinners were very good. The old fashioned cocktails were watered down, would not recommend.
Service was very good, dining area is small, which made the room very noisy. I may try again in the future, but it is not a must return for me.

Tod D.

3/5

Had dinner with friends on a Saturday night. We heard this place was small and it’s very small. Very quaint and cozy. Old Fashioned’s were great. We ordered dinner, soup and salad were very good. Also got a crusty baguette appetizer, very good. 1 buddy got the Salmon special that was very good. Another got the ribeye. It was delicious. Unfortunately I ordered the “Fish Fry.” It’s available everyday. When my dinner arrived I was immediately disappointed. The fish was a pre-battered frozen product. Absolutely NOT what I was expecting at a Wisconsin Supper Club. It was inedible. This needs to be removed from the menu. Fortunately the atmosphere, staff, service and rest of the meal was very good. Especially the service!! We will be back. Hopefully the fish is removed .

Syndee M.

5/5

Make a reservation! This place is great, but it's small so you'll need to plan ahead on Saturday. We were lucky enough to get two places at the bar, and enjoyed our steaks. They were cooked perfectly, as were the baked potato & veggie special of the day, Brussels sprouts ~ everything was delicious! Staff were super friendly even though they were running their behinds off.

Matt S.

5/5

We had a great experience at the Village supper club! Incredible food, and incredible value! You get free soup and salad with every entrée! The ambience is perfect Wisconsin supper club vibes. I would highly recommend this restaurant. Try the shrimp!

Laura K. (. E.

5/5

I always wanted to go to The Village Supper Club for Friday night fish fry,tonight was my night 3-8-2024.This supper club is delicious and a must 😋 The restaurant is small with about 15 tables and a very nice bar area.They surve in courses first clam chowder soup followed by a 4 piece cod dinner with your choice of sides(I got a baked potato)It was fantastic and we were so full.Price is very reasonable $36.00 for 2 people.(forgot to mention it also comes with a salad)

Roger S.

4/5

Great old school supper club, I've been going there for years and will continue to. Definitely, the prime rib must have, and their soups are always good. Nice cocktails.