Mama Mia Pie and Pasta - Davis, West Virginia

Ü L.

The food was tasty. The parking was easy. There was a little wait before they brought us the menu and the food. The restrooms were clean. The people who worked there were nice and helpful. There was an amazing view inside the restaurant. It's spacious. It could be a very good spot to hang out, too.

C H.

Visiting from NJ. The bruschetta was not what I expected, but was excellent. Service was so much better than other places we visited in the area. A very enjoyable experience.

John M.

Carry out order Friday Feb 14 - What could go wrong A 10” and 14” pie, a house salad, Greek salad and an order of calamari. Should be easy… our order was placed and paid for at 6:30 with pick up stated by staff to be ready by 7:30. The place is busy. We’re there at 7:30 for our order and there is a stream of patrons arriving to pick up their orders. But, every carry out order is behind by more than an hour. This is beyond a train wreck. Moms and Dads are upset and rightfully so. The staff is confused, disorganized and overwhelmed. Our order is ready except for the pizzas, the calamari is now cold. Told my pizzas would be ready in another 30 minutes but that estimate was wrong too. The manager excused the delay due to being busy. It was total chaos! This restaurant is poorly run! They need to be honest with their customers about order times. Do not spend your money here. The food was cold and mediocre at best. A frozen pizza from the Winking Owl would be a better choice and more timely. I negotiated a 50% discount but our evening was ruined owing to such a poor experience and delay.

Todd R.

Good beer selection, huge food menu. I ordered a hot antipasto appetizer that was awesome. It was loaded with spicy shrimp, sausage, clams and mussels and veggies and came with a bunch of garlic knots. Then I got a Momma's Special Calzone that was delicious.

Sheri W.

We ordered take-out pizza, because it was close to where we stayed. First I called to asked about what was on the specialty pizzas, because the link in the website to the descriptions wasn’t active. Pizza took an hour as they said.

Margarita pizza was really strange. We debated if we got the right pizza for a while, but we were hungry and started eating. It may have had 1 tiny diced tomato per slice, and it was covered in sweet balsamic dressing. If that’s your thing, great. Just not what we were expecting. Not a typical margarita pizza.

The Sicilian was nothing special either, and we were disappointed it barely had sauce.

The mama pizza was good.

Overall, we were disappointed. But this seemed to be the only pizza option.

Glory Y.

First time visiting and I must agree with other reviews saying service isn't great here. We waited more than 10 minutes and nobody came to our table. When they finally did I felt our server was sweet but for some reason they took so long and it felt awkward. The food was really good specially the wings and salad, I got the Caesar salad and stuffed shells and also we ordered Hawaiian pizza. The place is spacious and has a bar section and billar table for those who want to play. All servers seemed to be in a bad mood except for our waitress, she was friendly and attentive but the environment felt a bit hostile. I think the food is decent and surprisingly good for the restaurants location, literally in the middle of nowhere. Give it a shot maybe you are lucky to have friendly staff on the day you visit!

Christina D.

Excellent pasta dishes. Pizza is a standard NY Style and just ok. My manicotti was excellent. The ricotta mixture and sauce went together perfectly and the pasta was tender. My husband said his baked ziti was the best he’s had; being that his pasta was cooked perfectly. We both agreed the red sauce was thin, but still had great flavor. Garlic bread looked good, but was bland. The cheesecake was good and you can tell it’s made in house. While our waitress was really nice, I will say that service was slow. When we got there we walked in at the same time as another couple at the same time and we sat at the same time. Another couple walked in several minutes afterwards and they were greeted and had drinks before we even got a menu. We also had to hear the waitresses argue who was going to take our table. Not very professional. Food was slow to come out as well. The restaurant wasn’t busy. So while the food was really great, in future we would only consider going only if we have plenty of time. Prices are on the high side too.

Golden A. C.

We are regulars here and we LOVE the food at Mama Mia's!!! Everything we have had is stellar! The owners are such sweet people that take clearly great pride in their restaurant. Pro tip: when you come for dinner, sit in the bar area and have Tracy serve you! We've always sat in the main dining room and missed the opportunity to be waited on by the best server in Tucker County until tonight!