Farmstead Creamery & Cafe - Hayward, Wisconsin

Farmstead Creamery & Cafe: A Unique Destination

Farmstead Creamery & Cafe, located at 11077 Fullington Rd, Hayward, WI 54843, is a truly distinctive establishment that offers a multifaceted experience centered around farm-fresh products and a warm, inviting atmosphere. The business, proudly women-owned, operates as a combination of a farm, bakery, supermarket, ice cream shop, organic food shop, and even a wool shop – a remarkable blend that sets it apart. With a strong emphasis on community and local ingredients, it’s a destination that appeals to a wide range of visitors seeking quality and a connection to the land.

Location and Accessibility

The cafe’s location in Hayward, Wisconsin, contributes significantly to its charm. Situated a bit off the beaten path, it offers a respite from the hustle and bustle of more frequent tourist destinations. The address is 11077 Fullington Rd, Hayward, WI 54843, and they can be easily reached by phone at 7154623453. Furthermore, the establishment is committed to accessibility, boasting a wheelchair-accessible car park and wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that all visitors can enjoy the experience. This dedication to inclusivity is a testament to their values and commitment to serving the community.

A Diverse Range of Offerings

Farmstead Creamery & Cafe offers a surprisingly diverse selection of goods and services. Visitors can indulge in a variety of delectable treats, including homemade ice cream, a tempting array of bakery items, and refreshing beverages such as coffee and chai. On select Saturdays, they even offer pizzas, expanding their culinary repertoire. Beyond the sweet and savory, the shop showcases a curated collection of organic food, reflecting their commitment to sustainable and healthy choices. The wool shop component adds another layer to the experience, offering locally sourced wool products and potentially related crafts and supplies. Online ordering is available through their website, providing convenience for those who wish to enjoy their offerings from home.

Unique Features and Activities

What truly distinguishes Farmstead Creamery & Cafe is its unique focus on the farm and its animals. A charming pig resides on the property, a delightful addition that adds to the farm's atmosphere. The cafe provides a cozy seating area, including a few tables for outdoor enjoyment, creating a relaxed and inviting environment. They also offer craft project kits and classes, catering to those interested in hands-on activities and learning about various crafts. The concept of ‘fika,’ a Swedish tradition of enjoying coffee and pastries, is subtly incorporated, suggesting a welcoming and social atmosphere.

Customer Feedback and Reputation

The business has garnered considerable positive feedback from its patrons, evidenced by the 56 reviews on Google My Business. The average opinion is a remarkable 4.5/5, demonstrating a high level of customer satisfaction. Reviewers consistently praise the quality of the products, the friendly service, and the overall unique experience. The “quaint little spot off the beaten path” description frequently appears, highlighting its secluded charm and tranquil setting. Many customers express a fondness for the pig and the farm’s overall ambiance. The ease of curbside/to-go service further enhances the convenience for visitors.

Website and Contact Information

For more detailed information and to explore their offerings, visitors are encouraged to explore the website: northstarhomestead.com. This platform provides access to the latest menu, class schedules, and product availability. Direct contact can be established through the phone number 7154623453. Farmstead Creamery & Cafe presents itself as more than just a business; it's a community hub and a celebration of rural life and sustainable practices. It’s a destination promising a memorable and fulfilling experience for all who visit.

👍 Reviews of Farmstead Creamery & Cafe

Keian G.

5/5

A quaint little spot off the beaten path "celebrating all things sheep." Offering curbside/to-go service and having a couple tables for outdoor seating, they serve gelato, bakery treats, fika, coffee, chai, and pizzas on select Saturdays. Also available online, you'll find craft project kits and classes. My personal favorite aspect, though, is the little pig kept on site.

Krista F.

4/5

We went Sunday morning for their Bismarks (fluffy crepes). The food and coffee was delicious. Everything is either from their farm or locally sourced. I would definitely recommend the fresh strawberries. The service was a little slow but very friendly and knowledgeable. I'm sure they don't get parties of 6 adults + 4 kids often right at 9 AM. The kids loved the chickens, pigs, and watching the hummingbirds eat which helped the wait go by. They even got to feed the pigs the leftover scraps.

Cocobella

4/5

Really good waffles, a bit on the high. Otherwise I ordered savory option which was very delicious, freshly grown vegetables sauteed on top of my delicious waffle. It had such a nice crispy outside. There is a sweet choice in which berries grown on premise is the topping. The seating area is a lot smaller than I had imagined, very pretty though, with several needling kits ready for purchase. There are wool crafting classes that take place on the upper level. Really fantastic, fun, engaging, educational, and you leave with a nicely finished project.

Clark B.

5/5

Fun little place. Great gelato. A few friends too

Brandon F.

1/5

I was so excited to try this place. Reviews were great, food looked amazing. We came here for breakfast and it was great! There were a couple things that weren’t great customer service but we just thought it was a fluke (ex: when the lady passive aggressively informed a guest that there’s only two gelato samples. Also when my father in law asked for more syrup twice and the waitress looked at him and walked away). Then we heard about their pizza night so we decided to come! $30/pizza by the way, which is very expensive to me, ESPECIALLY after seeing what you get. They say the pizzas are for 2 people - the pizzas are small and could feed 1. They also said everyone gets a starter. We had 10 people so we ordered 5 pizzas (based off their recommendation). The starter was a tiny salad that two people had to share and only one fork. When we asked if we were getting more, a VERY passive aggressive announcement was made that they serve one salad per pizza. Some were laughing but most were cringing. The waiter (I think father?) also has no idea what he was doing. My friend has an allergy to dill and she asked if there was dill in the salad. He said there was not. I smelled dill so she asked again and sure enough, there was. During the same passive aggressive announcement, the man said “our signs clearly state if you have an allergy so please let us know. Everyone has different allergies and we can’t help you unless you tell us”.... but she DID tell him! He continued to come over to our table and argue with us about their integrity while we ate. We had couples so each couple shared a pizza. We all had to wait at least and hour and a half but one couple still hadn’t gotten their pizza (2 hours later I might add). The chef admitted that she gave their pizza to a table after us because they were complaining about the wait time. So we had to wait an extra 30 minutes for everyone to finish. As great as the farm to table experience is, the people there are arrogant and rude. I would never go back. Very disappointed.

Ken G.

5/5

I stopped in while on a bike ride this morning and it was wonderful! The coffee and bakery were superb and the outdoor seating was plentiful. I wish I had brought a bag so that I could have taken some fresh green and wax beans home. Next time...and I will be coming back to sample the grilled pizza. Add Farmstead to your list for farm-to-table goodness.

Greg C.

5/5

This our favorite place to eat at when we are in the area. The kale they sell is superb compared to what we can buy elsewhere. Wish we lived locally, we'd be buying from them all the time. The gelato is fantastic! The whole place & people are wonderful and amazing. Well worth a visit.

LISA J.

1/5

We ordered 3 pizzas and all 6 of us drank water and the bill was over $90. Ridiculous for 3 pizzas. Coming from a farming background some of the information given while dinning was questionable. Never to return. Very over priced for the experience.