Zeman's Old Highway House - Baraboo, Wisconsin

Zeman's Old Highway House

Located at 620 W Pine St, Baraboo, WI 53913, Zeman's Old Highway House is a renowned restaurant, bar & grill, catering service, fine dining restaurant, and seafood restaurant. With a variety of specialties and unique features, this establishment is perfect for any dining experience.

Specialties: Zeman's Old Highway House offers a range of specialties, including outdoor seating, takeout, dine-in, delivery, fast service, great beer selection, great cocktails, sports, lunch, dinner, solo dining, wheelchair accessible entrance, wheelchair accessible parking lot, wheelchair accessible restroom, wheelchair accessible seating, alcohol, beer, cocktails, coffee, comfort food, happy hour drinks, hard liquor, quick bite, small plates, wine, lunch, dinner, dessert, seating, bar onsite, restroom, Wi-Fi, Wi-Fi, casual, cozy, family-friendly, groups, tourists, accepts reservations, credit cards, debit cards, credit cards, good for kids, high chairs, kids' menu, free parking lot, free street parking, parking.

Opinions: This company has 357 reviews on Google My Business. With an impressive average rating of 4.3/5, Zeman's Old Highway House has garnered a strong reputation for its excellent dining and service.

Contact: For more information, call 844-824-47 or visit their website zemans-hh.com.

👍 Reviews of Zeman's Old Highway House

Jennifer H.

2/5

Stopped in on our way up North! The place was packed! It was a Friday night so of course we tried the fish fry! We tried the combo plate, 2 pieces of breaded cod, 2 breaded shrimp, we opted for the sidewinder fries. The fish was good, the breading ok. The shrimp were severely overcooked. The sidewinder fries were excellent. We also tried the stuffed shrimp. There were 5 large shrimp with a mushroom duxelle and crab stuffing topped with hollandaise sauce and melted cheese. Neither of us cared for these, I was looking for a more crab forward filling, they were definitely kind of wet. We opted to get the salad bar as well, typical WI salad bar, delicious. We tried the fried Brussel sprout appetizer which came with a horseradish sauce, these were pretty good. The dinner rolls were soft, fresh and very good. Our server was phenomenal. The bus girl on top of things like clearing plates, getting drink refills and bringing boxes.
It is VERY VERY VERY LOUD, great for a bar, not as great for dinner. The bathrooms are by the front door and although they were clean they keep the doors open, kind of uncomfortable as it is b the front door.
We would probably try this place again as they have quite a menu, but I wouldn’t go out of my way to eat here again.

T M. W.

4/5

Second time here on purpose.
Last month we happened in at dinner on prime rib night. Excellent!
Today we enjoyed patty melt lunch served by Diane. Excellent!

Travis R.

5/5

We had the pleasure to have Shannon as our waitress, and she was an absolute pleasure!
My wife had the Wisco burger which was very good! I had the jalapeno burger and also very good with nice spice! The side winder fries were a great hit! We will be coming back for sure!
The miss matched tables and chairs are great. We found the decor great!!

Char T. K.

4/5

Enjoyed our meal. A meat and fish restaurant. Nice atmosphere. Felt like you eating at a table in your home. Good service. They were busy so we waited a little long for our food. The mixed drinks were good and an extremely fair priced. I had the wild mushroom ravioli. My dinner mates had Marsala chicken (she wished it had a little more sauce on it and Ruben sandwich with fries. Not many choices for vegetarians. The one they had was excellent. We will go there again. I thought the salad was very pretty.

Mercedes S.

5/5

Food was very good and good hearty portions. The old fashions... one of the best I've ever tried excellent!!!

Reuben J.

5/5

I was in town on business, and I have heard good things about Zeman's, so I decided to stop in for dinner. The bartender was fast, attentive, and has a good sense of humor. He did a great job. I ordered the pan seared walleye and doubled up on mashed potatoes. The food arrived sooner than I expected, which is always nice. In this day in age, it's a rarity to get HOT food when it gets to you. My meal was piping hot, and incredibly delicious. One of the best meals, and dining experiences I have ever had. I live in Kentucky, so I rarely get to the Midwest. Zeman's is warm, inviting, and I highly recommend it. I will definitely be back.

Maria F.

5/5

The ribs were falling off the bone tender and so meaty! Our server was very attentive and helpful. The chef had a question about a special order and came to personally follow up with us about it - with grace. Thanks for a great meal!

Tara M.

5/5

We probably had the best prime rib in the area. The restaurant section was very comfortable, our waitress was a gem and the prime rib and green beans were absolutely fantastic. Plus a salad bar was included. We will be back for sure and highly recommend.