Secret Sandwich Society - Fayetteville, West Virginia

Matt B.

FOOD: We started out with the pimento cheese fries. We upgraded to ones with jalapenos and crumbled bacon. Very tasty perfect crisp and the cheese and bacon combo was so good. I got the Lady Bird sandwich (the one with the potato roll bun) quite delicious chicken, bacon, and chipotle mayo is a great dish. My girlfriend ordered the Rose Marie. Turkey, rosemary mayo, the works on toasted sourdough bread. I preferred hers slightly more. It was more flavorful.

Service: our waiter was just the right amount of attentiveness. Our food came quickly and was fresh. No complaints!

Atmosphere: we chose to sit outside. The inside looked very modern and very comfortable. Outside would be better if the deck walls were lower to see out while dining here. (Very nitpicking complaint but sitting outside, i prefer a view. ) it's a covered patio and it was a great day for outside !

Kari P.

This place was fun! Love the building, the service was great— food was to rave about. Happy I could visit and look forward to getting back next time in town! I had a Beyond Burger and it was delicious!

Olivia R.

Let me tell y'all something. If you're ever in this area of WV this place is a MUST go to!
The best sandwiches I've ever had. The service was amazing, the inside was super sleek and clean.
The food and everything about it tasted, looked, smelled and was fresh!

I got the Rose Marie sandwhich with the chips and a side salad with melon ceaser dressing. The chips were some of the best house made chips I've had. They were super crunch and not soggy at all. The turkey on the sandwhich tasted like Thanksgiving turkey, and was so moist. The bread was toasted amazingly as well!
Highly highly recommend!

Zak M.

Absolutely excellent spot for lunch anytime, but especially when visit New River Gorge National Park. There was a modern interior with unique sandwich and burger options. Everything tasted great. They make everything fresh as well. It means a bit of a wait for food, but it is well worth it!

Daryl D.

We've tried to eat here several times but they were always too busy (for food reason). We finally got in and loved it. I got the "Velvet," a burger with swiss cheese, caramelized onions, and french onion dip. Delicious! My wife got the Rose Marie, essentially a turtle, but delicious. We also got the pimento cheese fries: yum! Servers and atmosphere were great.

Peg P.

Stopped on the way South and so glad we did. Service was great and sandwiches were very good. Chips come with the sandwiches but we upgraded to the truffle fries. So good. He loved the homemade pickles. We got the Eisenhower and the Hoover and 2 Cokes. $51.89 with tax. Definitely worth a visit.

Jeff H. (.

So glad the Secret is back! I have been waiting forever for those pimento cheese fries! The wait here will be awhile so I recommend reserving a table and then going to town and visiting the shops for an hour and a half. That’s how long our wait was but it flew by as we went to every single place in Fayetteville of note.

We are outside and the weather was absolutely perfect. The atmosphere was great and server was very good. She was kind and knowledgeable and was able to handle all of our needs and questions.

There wasn’t a bad thing I had that day and I can’t wait to return to try the other items on the menu. But the impossible burger I had was perfect. I could eat it everyday. I’m not even vegan or anything and I still eat meat. I just think they taste really good. I love how they set water out for you to just go and refill it yourself at your leisure. I’m a big fan of that also. I

The parking is limited so you may have to walk a bit to get back as cross the street in a few precious spots so be careful. But once you arrive you will not be disappointed.

Robin R.

Started with Pimento Cheese Fries, which were outstanding. Three people got burgers with Parmesan Truffle fries, so good. One turkey sandwich, which was also amazing.