Pies & Pints - Fayetteville, WV - Fayetteville, West Virginia

Benjy B.

I am SO glad I decided to come here!

The location itself is cool and has a variety of seating, but both the food and service were incredible. The beer selection is great, the ceasar salad was among the best I’ve ever had, and the white pizza with pepperoni was wonderful. My only regret is ordering too much without having a fridge to store things in since I’m camping.

I also want to shout out Cora as being an 11/10 server. She was so kind and friendly, was super knowledgeable about the place, about town, and about the national park, and she went out of her way to answer any questions people had about the area. Seriously one of the best servers I’ve ever had!

Jennifer M.

Hiked some hard ass trails and earned some pizza and beer! Their pies are unique and delicious! Our waiter was awesome and gave us some recommendations. We loved the goat cheese appetizer and our pizza was delicious as well. There's a nice spot to hang out outside while you wait with access to the bar. Will definitely visit again next time we're in town for the park.

Jeff W.

This is my first time here. We were visiting for Bridge day and stopped in for dinner and a couple beers. I gave it a four out of five stars because I’m a bit of a beer stop and lean more towards craft beers. I like ones that are kind of happy and lean more towards double IPAs. I just thought most of the beer here was kind of subpar. Some of the cocktails tasted very good though. The service was good, the atmosphere was great, and the pizza was good.

Will M.

What a great place to enjoy your lunch. Service was great, food was exceptional. Try the Italian Hero and the Margherita Pizza!

Jennifer W.

Order early! By far the best pizza I have ever eaten. We ordered take out on Sunday evening. Pizza was cooked to order, salad was made to order, the wings were HOT and everything was delicious. The beer was really tasty too! My only complaint is we didn't get any forks for our salad and we didn't have any at our cabin either, so I ate the salad on the way home on Monday after getting a fork at a gas station 😔.

John K.

Pies and Pints - Fayetteville, WV. is nothing short of amazing!!! We when to the gorge bridge and while at the bottom of the gorge ran into a couple getting married on the lower bridge. What a beautiful spot to be married. After the wedding we were walking off the bridge with the preacher and he asked if we had dinner plans. We responded we did not. He recommended Pies and Pints, as he said it was amazing. Well, when you get a recommendation from a preacher man you have to go with it right? We did and the pizza was over the moon good!!! Can I give it 10 stars? The staff was also supper friendly and our waitress was excellent. They were getting ready to close up when we left and had a good chat with our waitress and several other workers that were just sitting down to eat pizza themselves. This is the original Pies & Pints and is a must do. The waitress recommended reservations as normally they don't have seating available most days/nights. Pies and Pints was an amazing way to finish our amazing day with an amazing pizza!!!

Jeanatan H.

Local favourite slinging inventive pies and craft brews. Service was kind and attentive, even at peak custom. I ordered a Thai pie (shrimp, coconut, curry, lime, cilantro, basil on a thin crust) and it was not only well-crafted and perfectly cooked, but quite possibly one of the best pizzas I have ever eaten (then again, I do love Thai food). The draft root beer was also excellent - smooth with a hint of vanilla, but not overwhelmingly sweet. Highly recommend this restaurant - make a reservation!

Gwen C.

Excellent quality pizza, salad and beer with equally good service. Our server tonight had personally galore. If you are a pizza crust snob, you will love this place. It’s light, crispy and flavorful.