Casa D'Amici - White Hall, West Virginia

Honest R.

Atmosphere-3 stars- small pizza joint located at Middletown Commons. Nothing fancy but decent for takeout or a quick bite.

Service- 3 stars- hard to rank this cause it’s counter service. Employees are friendly enough.

Food- 4 stars- good New York style pizza. I like that you can get a slice or a whole pizza. They have a variety of subs, salads and other deep fried appetizers.

Kevin D.

This place is great. ... thanks for opening in the Whitehall/Fairmont area! The food is always excellent, the workers are friendly, and service is prompt. We drop by when we want a fast bite to eat and have never been disappointed!

Alfredo R.

5/5 overall pizza

Very yummy pizza, crust was nice and soft yet crunchy, delicious sause and cheese and more importantly the ratio of cheese and sause was good. Respectfully amount of toppings- everything fresh. Only improvement would be slightly thinner curse for that true NY style.

The restaurant and the workers were very nice, and kind to the kids even giving stickers and candy ! Clean and spacious interior 👌.

Elizabeth R.

my friend & i love ceaser, who is often working the counter! he is so personable, kind, and the best service worker ever! give him a raise! The pizza is to die for, and the garlic knots. we absolutely love this restaurant, and suggest it.

Kimi V.

A lot of options!!! I got the deal for 2 slices and a fountain drink for $7. They had about 8-10 different pizzas to choose a slice from (including specialty pizzas) and the man at the counter was very helpful in explaining what each one was! The slices were very big and fresh! They cook your slice in the oven, so the bottom is crispy and fresh! Traditional New York style thin slices. Mine were finished in about 3 minutes and they brought it over to me! You can add parmesan cheese and red pepper flakes. I got the pepperoni and a buffalo chicken slice. The pepperoni was definitely my favorite, but both were so good! I'll definitely be back 🙂

Mary F. (.

Absolutely fabulous experience here! Delicious food and fantastic people. Great atmosphere.

Andria H. G.

The first time I saw this place they had just opened up. I came in and the workers were really friendly and helpful. I was impressed they still sold pizza by the slice, and cheap too. I had the white pizza by the slice, which was delicious. Tonight, I ordered via doordash. They have a one large topping pizza and dozen wing deal for $25.99, which is a steal. When the pizza arrived, the slices were as large, if not larger than my head. The pizza box will not fit in your fridge and it will cover the entire stove top. When they say large, they aren't messing around. They have that thin homemade hand tossed dough, that holds it's shape and doesn't fall on you, but is also deliciously foldable. The sauce has that taste you wish everywhere had, very delicious!!! 👌🔥 The wings were large in size. I asked for well done, and they were both crispy and juicy, which I appreciate! I also enjoyed that their wings aren't battered. I ordered garlic parm. The seasonings and cheese on the wings were delicious, but most of the sauce dripped to the bottom (common with a garlic parm wing). Still very flavorful. I definitely will be back, as I am dying to try many of their flavor specialities and wing sauces!

Aria W.

Finally got to try their garlic knots and they are absolutely delicious!!! I highly recommend eating here!!!